Create Chicklet (Rounded Segmented Column) Charts https://cinc.rud.is/web/packages/ggchicklet/
You can not select more than 25 topics Topics must start with a letter or number, can include dashes ('-') and can be up to 35 characters long.
 
 

418 lines
183 KiB

<!DOCTYPE html>
<html lang="en" itemId="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/31/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html" itemType="http://schema.org/NewsArticle" itemScope="" xmlns:og="http://opengraphprotocol.org/schema/">
<head>
<title data-rh="true">Joe Biden and Kamala Harris Got the Most Speaking Time During the Democratic Debate - The New York Times</title>
<meta data-rh="true" itemprop="inLanguage" content="en-US"/><meta data-rh="true" property="article:published" itemprop="datePublished dateCreated" content="2019-08-01T00:11:48.000Z"/><meta data-rh="true" property="article:modified" itemprop="dateModified" content="2019-08-01T03:13:02.062Z"/><meta data-rh="true" http-equiv="Content-Language" content="en"/><meta data-rh="true" name="robots" content="noarchive"/><meta data-rh="true" name="articleid" itemprop="identifier" content="100000006640050"/><meta data-rh="true" name="nyt_uri" itemprop="identifier" content="nyt://interactive/0fdf9ad9-54f9-591e-a71e-7477603238cb"/><meta data-rh="true" name="pubp_event_id" itemprop="identifier" content="pubp://event/d830aecb44bd4924ace0e47654082301"/><meta data-rh="true" name="description" itemprop="description" content="Follow along live during the debate."/><meta data-rh="true" name="image" itemprop="image" content="https://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/07/31/multimedia/dem-debate/dem-debate-facebookJumbo-v14.jpg"/><meta data-rh="true" name="byl" content="By Weiyi Cai, Jasmine C. Lee, Juliette Love and Alicia Parlapiano"/><meta data-rh="true" name="thumbnail" itemprop="thumbnailUrl" content="https://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/07/31/multimedia/dem-debate/dem-debate-thumbStandard-v10.jpg"/><meta data-rh="true" name="news_keywords" content="2020 Election,Democrats"/><meta data-rh="true" name="pdate" content="20190731"/><meta data-rh="true" property="og:url" content="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/31/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html"/><meta data-rh="true" property="og:type" content="article"/><meta data-rh="true" property="og:title" content="Joe Biden and Kamala Harris Got the Most Speaking Time During the Democratic Debate"/><meta data-rh="true" property="og:image" content="https://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/07/31/multimedia/dem-debate/dem-debate-facebookJumbo-v14.jpg"/><meta data-rh="true" property="og:description" content="Follow along live during the debate."/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:url" content="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/31/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html"/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:title" content="Joe Biden and Kamala Harris Got the Most Speaking Time During the Democratic Debate"/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:description" content="Follow along live during the debate."/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:image" content="https://static01.nyt.com/images/2019/07/31/multimedia/dem-debate/dem-debate-videoSixteenByNineJumbo1600-v14.jpg"/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:image:alt" content=""/><meta data-rh="true" property="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/><meta data-rh="true" property="article:section" itemprop="articleSection" content="U.S."/><meta data-rh="true" property="article:tag" content="Presidential Election of 2020"/><meta data-rh="true" property="article:tag" content="Democratic Party"/><meta data-rh="true" name="CG" content="us"/><meta data-rh="true" name="SCG" content="elections"/><meta data-rh="true" name="CN" content="2020-election"/><meta data-rh="true" name="CT" content="news-event"/>
<meta charset="utf-8" />
<meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge" />
<meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1, maximum-scale=1" />
<meta property="fb:app_id" content="9869919170" />
<meta name="twitter:site" value="@nytimes" />
<link data-rh="true" rel="alternate" itemprop="mainEntityOfPage" hrefLang="en-US" href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/31/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html"/><link data-rh="true" rel="canonical" href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/31/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html"/>
<script type="text/javascript">
// 20.103kB
window.viHeadScriptSize = 20.103;
(function () { var _f=function(e){window.vi=window.vi||{},window.vi.env=Object.freeze(e)};;_f.apply(null, [{"JKIDD_PATH":"https://a.nytimes.com/svc/nyt/data-layer","ET2_URL":"https://a.et.nytimes.com","WEDDINGS_PATH":"https://content.api.nytimes.com","GDPR_PATH":"https://us-central1-nyt-wfvi-prd.cloudfunctions.net/gdpr-email-form","RECAPTCHA_SITEKEY":"6LevSGcUAAAAAF-7fVZF05VTRiXvBDAY4vBSPaTF","ABRA_ET_URL":"//et.nytimes.com","NODE_ENV":"production","SENTRY_SAMPLE_RATE":"10","EXPERIMENTAL_ROUTE_PREFIX":"","ENVIRONMENT":"prd","RELEASE":"fc471d2d4bdbc8bfce26563e6af5d1237c2f9200","AUTH_HOST":"https://myaccount.nytimes.com","SWG_PUBLICATION_ID":"nytimes.com","GQL_FETCH_TIMEOUT":"4000","GOOGLE_CLIENT_ID":"1005640118348-amh5tgkq641oru4fbhr3psm3gt2tcc94.apps.googleusercontent.com"}]); })();;
!function(){if('PerformanceLongTaskTiming' in window){var g=window.__tti={e:[]};
g.o=new PerformanceObserver(function(l){g.e=g.e.concat(l.getEntries())});
g.o.observe({entryTypes:['longtask']})}}();
;
!function(n,e){var t,o,i,c=[],f={passive:!0,capture:!0},r=new Date,a="pointerup",u="pointercancel";function p(n,c){t||(t=c,o=n,i=new Date,w(e),s())}function s(){o>=0&&o<i-r&&(c.forEach(function(n){n(o,t)}),c=[])}function l(t){if(t.cancelable){var o=(t.timeStamp>1e12?new Date:performance.now())-t.timeStamp;"pointerdown"==t.type?function(t,o){function i(){p(t,o),r()}function c(){r()}function r(){e(a,i,f),e(u,c,f)}n(a,i,f),n(u,c,f)}(o,t):p(o,t)}}function w(n){["click","mousedown","keydown","touchstart","pointerdown"].forEach(function(e){n(e,l,f)})}w(n),self.perfMetrics=self.perfMetrics||{},self.perfMetrics.onFirstInputDelay=function(n){c.push(n),s()}}(addEventListener,removeEventListener);
;try {
var observer = new window.PerformanceObserver(function (list) {
var entries = list.getEntries();
for (var i = 0; i < entries.length; i += 1) {
var entry = entries[i];
var performance = {};
performance[entry.name] = Math.round(entry.startTime + entry.duration);
(window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []).push({
event: "performance",
pageview: {
performance: performance
}
});
}
});
observer.observe({
entryTypes: ["paint"]
});
} catch (e) {};
!function(i,e){var a,s,c,p,u,g=[],
l="object"==typeof i.navigator&&"string"==typeof i.navigator.userAgent&&/iP(ad|hone|od)/.test(
i.navigator.userAgent),f="object"==typeof i.navigator&&i.navigator.sendBeacon,
y=f?l?"xhr_ios":"beacon":"xhr";function d(){var e,t,n=i.crypto||i.msCrypto;if(n)t=n.getRandomValues(
new Uint8Array(18));else for(t=[];t.length<18;)t.push(256*Math.random()^255&(e=e||+new Date)),
e=Math.floor(e/256);return btoa(String.fromCharCode.apply(String,t)).replace(/\+/g,"-").replace(
/\//g,"_")}if(i.nyt_et)try{console.warn("et2 snippet should only load once per page")}catch(e
){}else i.nyt_et=function(){var e,t,n,o=arguments;function r(r){g.length&&(function(e,t,n){if(
"beacon"===y||f&&r)return i.navigator.sendBeacon(e,t)
;var o="undefined"!=typeof XMLHttpRequest?new XMLHttpRequest:new ActiveXObject("Microsoft.XMLHTTP")
;o.open("POST",e),o.withCredentials=!0,o.setRequestHeader("Accept","*/*"),
"string"==typeof t?o.setRequestHeader("Content-Type","text/plain;charset=UTF-8"
):"[object Blob]"==={}.toString.call(t)&&t.type&&o.setRequestHeader("Content-Type",t.type);try{
o.send(t)}catch(e){}}(a+"/track",JSON.stringify(g)),g.length=0,clearTimeout(u),u=null)}if(
"string"==typeof o[0]&&/init/.test(o[0])&&(c=d(),"init"==o[0]&&!s)){if(s=d(),
"string"!=typeof o[1]||!/^http/.test(o[1]))throw new Error("init must include an et host url")
;a=String(o[1]).replace(/\/$/,""),"string"==typeof o[2]&&(p=o[2])}n="page_exit"==(e=o[o.length-1]
).subject||"ob_click"==(e.eventData||{}).type,a&&"object"==typeof e&&(t="page"==e.subject?c:d(),
e.sourceApp&&(p=e.sourceApp),e.sourceApp=p,g.push({context_id:s,pageview_id:c,event_id:t,
client_lib:"v1.0.5",sourceApp:p,how:n&&l&&f?"beacon_ios":y,client_ts:+new Date,data:JSON.parse(
JSON.stringify(e))}),"send"==o[0]||t==c||n?r(n):u||(u=setTimeout(r,5500)))},
i.nyt_et.get_pageview_id=function(){return c}}(window);
;
var NYTD=NYTD||{};NYTD.Abra=function(t){"use strict";function e(t){var e=r[t];return e&&e[1]||null}function n(t,e){if(t){var n,r,o=e[0],i=e[1],c=0,u=0;if(1!==i.length||4294967296!==i[0])for(n=a(t+" "+o)>>>0,c=0,u=0;r=i[c++];)if(n<(u+=r[0]))return r}}function a(t){for(var e,n,a,r,o,i,c,u=0,h=0,l=[],s=[e=1732584193,n=4023233417,~e,~n,3285377520],f=[],p=t.length;h<=p;)f[h>>2]|=(h<p?t.charCodeAt(h):128)<<8*(3-h++%4);for(f[c=p+8>>2|15]=p<<3;u<=c;u+=16){for(e=s,h=0;h<80;e=[0|[(i=((t=e[0])<<5|t>>>27)+e[4]+(l[h]=h<16?~~f[u+h]:i<<1|i>>>31)+1518500249)+((n=e[1])&(a=e[2])|~n&(r=e[3])),o=i+(n^a^r)+341275144,i+(n&a|n&r|a&r)+882459459,o+1535694389][0|h++/20],t,n<<30|n>>>2,a,r])i=l[h-3]^l[h-8]^l[h-14]^l[h-16];for(h=5;h;)s[--h]=s[h]+e[h]|0}return s[0]}var r,o={};return t.dataLayer=t.dataLayer||[],e.init=function(e){var a,o,i,c,u,h,l,s,f,p,d=[],v=[],m=(t.document.cookie.match(/(?:^|;) *nyt-a=([^;]*)/)||[])[1],b=(t.document.cookie.match(/(?:^|;) *ab7=([^;]*)/)||[])[1],g=(t.location.search.match(/(?:^\?|&)abra=([^&]*)/)||[])[1];if(r)throw new Error("can't init twice");for(r={},u=(decodeURIComponent(b||"")+"&"+decodeURIComponent(g||"")).split("&"),a=u.length-1;a>=0;a--)h=u[a].split("="),h.length<2||(l=h[0])&&!r[l]&&(s=h[1]||null,r[l]=[,s,1],s&&d.push(l+"="+s),v.push({test:l,variant:s||"0"}));for(a=0;a<e.length;a++)i=e[a],(o=i[0])in r||(c=n(m,i)||[],c[0],f=c[1],p=!!c[2],r[o]=c,f&&d.push(o.replace(/[^\w-]/g)+"="+(""+f).replace(/[^\w-]/g)),p&&v.push({test:o,variant:f||"0"}));d.length&&t.document.documentElement.setAttribute("data-nyt-ab",d.join(" ")),v.length&&t.dataLayer.push({event:"ab-alloc",abtest:{batch:v}})},e.reportExposure=function(e,n){if(!o[e]){o[e]=1;var a=r[e];if(a){var i=a[1];a[2]&&t.dataLayer.push({event:"ab-expose",abtest:{test:e,variant:i||"0"}})}n&&t.setTimeout(function(){n(null)},0)}},e}(this);
;(function () { var NYTD=window.NYTD||{};function setupTimeZone(){var e='[data-timezone][data-timezone~="'+(new Date).getHours()+'"] { display: block }',t=document.createElement("style");t.innerHTML=e,document.head.appendChild(t)}function addNYTAppClass(){var e=window.navigator.userAgent||window.navigator.vendor||window.opera,t=-1!==e.indexOf("nyt_android"),n=-1!==e.indexOf("nytios");(t||n)&&document.documentElement.classList.add("NYTApp")}function setupPageViewId(){NYTD.PageViewId={},NYTD.PageViewId.update=function(){return"undefined"!=typeof nyt_et&&"function"==typeof window.nyt_et.get_pageview_id?(window.nyt_et("pageinit"),NYTD.PageViewId.current=window.nyt_et.get_pageview_id()):NYTD.PageViewId.current="xxxxxxxx-xxxx-4xxx-yxxx-xxxxxxxxxxxx".replace(/[xy]/g,function(e){var t=16*Math.random()|0;return("x"===e?t:3&t|8).toString(16)}),NYTD.PageViewId.current}}var _f=function(e){try{document.domain="nytimes.com"}catch(e){}window.swgUserInfoXhrObject=new XMLHttpRequest,window.__emotion=e.emotionIds,setupPageViewId(),setupTimeZone(),addNYTAppClass(),window.nyt_et("init",vi.env.ET2_URL,"nyt-vi",{subject:"page",canonicalUrl:(document.querySelector("link[rel=canonical]")||{}).href,articleId:(document.querySelector("meta[name=articleid]")||{}).content,nyt_uri:(document.querySelector("meta[name=nyt_uri]")||{}).content,pubpEventId:(document.querySelector("meta[name=pubp_event_id]")||{}).content,url:location.href,referrer:document.referrer||void 0,client_tz_offset:(new Date).getTimezoneOffset()}),"undefined"!=typeof nyt_et&&"function"==typeof window.nyt_et.get_pageview_id?NYTD.PageViewId.current=window.nyt_et.get_pageview_id():NYTD.PageViewId.update(),NYTD.Abra.init(e.abraConfig,vi.env.ABRA_ET_URL)};;_f.apply(null, [{"emotionIds":["nuvmzp","1gz70xg","9e9ivx","2bwtzy","6n7j50","1kj7lfb","10m9xeu","vz7hjd","1fe7a5q","1rn5q1r","10488qs","1iruc8t","1ropbjl","uw59u","jxzr5i","oylsik","1otr2jl","1c8n994","qtw155","v0l3hm","g4gku8","1rr4qq7","6xhk3s","rxqrcl","tj0ten","ist4u3","1gprdgz","10t7hia","mzqdl","kwpx34","1k2cjfc","1vhk1ks","6td9kr","r5ic95","15uy5yv","1p8nkc0","1hyfx7x","5j8bii","1am0aiv","17ih8de","8atqhb","k2fwhk","1157aqr","y8aj3r","60hakz","1baulvz","i29ckm","1vegfwe","dehhk5","f8wsfj","mhvv8m","m6999o","cfo9c3","1m9j9gf","1q1yk17","g7rb99","ghw4n2","1c5cfvc","htgkrt","e64et","9zaqp9","16fq4rz","1kjk1j2","88g286","12yx39b","4hu8jm","1wqz2f4","yl3z84","1q3gjvc","nc39ev","amd09y","ru1vxe","ajnadh","b7n1on","1b9egsl","1egl8em","7y3qfv","1bymuyk","1waixk9","1f7ibof","l2ztic","19lv58h","mgtjo2","1wr3we4","10698na","nhjhh0","y3sf94","1bnxwmn","1i8g3m4","15hmgas","uqyvli","1uqjmks","1bvtpon","16ogagc","4brsb6","uhuo44","ar1l6a","mn5hq9","1qmnftd","1ho5u4o","13o0c9t","1yo489b","1s4ffep","1riqqik","o15hd4","brak7x","jqthw3","n4ogti","rqw92o","1p8vgzh","1c5207x","15n42zn"],"abraConfig":[["vi-ads-et",[[257698038,"2_remainder",1],[4037269258,null,0]]],["dfp_adslot4v2",[[4294967296,"1_external",1]]],["DFP_als",[[4294967296,"1_als",1]]],["DFP_als_home",[[4294967296,"1_als",1]]],["medianet_toggle",[[4294967296,"0_default",0]]],["amazon_toggle",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["index_toggle",[[4294967296,"1_block",0]]],["dfp_home_toggle",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["dfp_story_toggle",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["dfp_interactive_toggle",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["FREEX_Best_In_Show",[[2147483648,"0_Control",1],[2147483648,"1_Best",1]]],["MKT_dfp_ocean_language",[[2147483648,"0_control",1],[2147483648,"1_language",1]]],["STORY_topical_recirc",[[2147483648,"0_control",1],[2147483648,"1_variant",1]]],["HOME_timesExclusive",[[2147483648,"0_control",1],[2147483648,"1_variant",1]]],["MKT_GateDockMsgTap",[[715827883,"2_BAUDockTapGate",1],[715827883,"4_BAUDockRBGate",1],[1431655765,"2_BAUDockTapGate",1],[1431655765,"4_BAUDockRBGate",1]]],["SEARCH_FACET_DROPDOWN",[[2147483648,"0_FACET_MULTI_SELECT",1],[2147483648,"1_DYNAMIC_FACET_SELECT",1]]],["VG_gift_upsell_x_only",[[429496730,"0_control",1],[3865470566,"1_upsell",1]]],["FREEX_LIRE_SPLIT",[[2147483648,"0_LIRE",0],[2147483648,"1_FREEX",0]]],["FREEX_RegiWall_Truncator_v2",[[715827883,"0_Control_Stories_RW",1],[715827883,"1_Stories_Truncator_dz1",1],[715827882,"2_LIRE_RW",1],[715827883,"3_LIRE_Truncator_dz1",1],[715827883,"4_Stories_Truncator_dz2",1],[715827882,"5_LIRE_Truncator_dz2",1]]],["ON_getstarted_app_dl_0819",[[4294967296,"1_appExperience",1]]],["ON_login_interrupt_0819",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["ON_app_dl_mc4_0919",[[4294967296,null,0]]],["MKT_dfp_EDU_BTS_Offer_Test",[[2147483648,"0_controloffer",1],[2147483648,"1_testoffer",1]]],["STYLN_menu_v1",[[4294967296,"1_menu_a",1]]],["STYLN_guide_v1",[[2147483648,"0_control_STYLN_guide_v1",1],[2147483648,"1_guide_v1",1]]],["STYLN_menu_v2",[[4294967296,"1_menu_v2",1]]],["STYLN_menu_brexit",[[4080218932,"1_menu_brexit",1],[214748364,"0_control_STYLN_menu_brexit",1]]],["STYLN_menu_hongkong",[[4080218932,"1_menu_hongkong",1],[214748364,"0_control_STYLN_menu_hongkong",1]]],["STYLN_menu_trump",[[4080218932,"1_menu_trump",1],[214748364,"0_control_STYLN_menu_trump",1]]],["STYLN_menu_election_live",[[1431655766,"2_menu_election_live",1],[1431655765,"1_menu_election_live",1],[1431655765,"0_control_STYLN_menu_election_live",1]]],["AUTH_RWEmailFirst",[[1073741824,"0_control",1],[1073741824,"1_CTAemailfirst",1],[1073741824,"2_noCTABAU",1],[1073741824,"3_noCTAemailfirst",1]]],["STORY_intentional_links_v1",[[1073741824,"0_control",0],[1073741824,"1_top_link",0],[1073741824,"2_mid_link",0],[1073741824,"3_btm_link",0]]],["HL_sample",[[2147483648,"0",1],[2147483648,"1",1]]],["HL_100000006707395",[[2147483648,"0",1],[2147483648,"1",1]]],["HL_100000006709587",[[2147483648,"0",1],[2147483648,"1",1]]]]}]); })();;(function () { var _f=function(e){var r=function(){var r=e.url;try{r+=window.location.search.slice(1).split("&").reduce(function(e,r){return"ip-override"===r.split("=")[0]?"?"+r:e},"")}catch(e){console.warn(e)}var n=new XMLHttpRequest;for(var t in n.withCredentials=!0,n.open("POST",r,!0),n.setRequestHeader("Content-Type","application/json"),e.headers)n.setRequestHeader(t,e.headers[t]);return n.send(e.body),n};window.userXhrObject=r(),window.userXhrRefresh=function(){return window.userXhrObject=r(),window.userXhrObject}};;_f.apply(null, [{"url":"https://samizdat-graphql.nytimes.com/graphql/v2","body":"{\"operationName\":\"UserQuery\",\"variables\":{},\"query\":\" query UserQuery { user { __typename profile { displayName } userInfo { regiId entitlements demographics { emailSubscriptions wat bundleSubscriptions { bundle inGrace promotion source } } } subscriptionDetails { graceStartDate graceEndDate isFreeTrial hasQueuedSub startDate endDate status entitlements } } } \"}","headers":{"nyt-app-type":"project-vi","nyt-app-version":"0.0.5","nyt-token":"MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAs+/oUCTBmD/cLdmcecrnBMHiU/pxQCn2DDyaPKUOXxi4p0uUSZQzsuq1pJ1m5z1i0YGPd1U1OeGHAChWtqoxC7bFMCXcwnE1oyui9G1uobgpm1GdhtwkR7ta7akVTcsF8zxiXx7DNXIPd2nIJFH83rmkZueKrC4JVaNzjvD+Z03piLn5bHWU6+w+rA+kyJtGgZNTXKyPh6EC6o5N+rknNMG5+CdTq35p8f99WjFawSvYgP9V64kgckbTbtdJ6YhVP58TnuYgr12urtwnIqWP9KSJ1e5vmgf3tunMqWNm6+AnsqNj8mCLdCuc5cEB74CwUeQcP2HQQmbCddBy2y0mEwIDAQAB"}}]); })();;(function () { var registry=window._interactiveRegistry={};function getId(t){for(;(t=t.parentElement)&&!t.matches("[data-sourceid].interactive-body"););return t?t.getAttribute("data-sourceid"):null}window.registerInteractive=function(t){var e={_subs:{cleanup:[]},id:t,on:function(t,r){return this._subs[t].push(r),e}};registry[t]=e},window.getInteractiveBridge=function(t){var e="string"==typeof t?t:getId(t);return registry[e]}; })();;100*Math.random()<=vi.env.SENTRY_SAMPLE_RATE?(window.INSTALL_RAVEN=!0,window.nyt_errors={ravenInstalled:!1,list:[],tags:[]},window.onerror=function(n,r,o,w,i){if(!window.nyt_errors.ravenInstalled){var t={err:i,data:{}};window.nyt_errors.list.push(t)}}):window.INSTALL_RAVEN=!1;;(function () { var _f=function(t,e,n){var a=window,A=document,o=function(t){var e=A.createElement("style");e.appendChild(A.createTextNode(t)),A.querySelector("head").appendChild(e)},r=function(t,e,n,a,A){var r=new XMLHttpRequest;r.open("GET",t,!0),r.onreadystatechange=function(){if(4===r.readyState&&200===r.status){o(r.responseText);try{localStorage.setItem("nyt-fontFormat",e),localStorage.setItem(a,n)}catch(t){return}localStorage.setItem(A,r.responseText)}return!0},r.send(null)},c=function(e,n){var A;try{A=localStorage.getItem("nyt-fontFormat")}catch(t){}A||(A=function(){if(!("FontFace"in a))return!1;var t=new FontFace("t",'url("data:application/font-woff2;base64,d09GMgABAAAAAADcAAoAAAAAAggAAACWAAEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABk4ALAoUNAE2AiQDCAsGAAQgBSAHIBtvAcieB3aD8wURQ+TZazbRE9HvF5vde4KCYGhiCgq/NKPF0i6UIsZynbP+Xi9Ng+XLbNlmNz/xIBBqq61FIQRJhC/+QA/08PJQJ3sK5TZFMlWzC/iK5GUN40psgqvxwBjBOg6JUSJ7ewyKE2AAaXZrfUB4v+hze37ugJ9d+DeYqiDwVgCawviwVFGnuttkLqIMGivmDg") format("woff2")',{});return t.load().catch(function(){}),"loading"==t.status||"loaded"==t.status}()?"woff2":"woff");for(var c=0;c<e.length;c++){var i=e[c],l="shared"!==i?"-"+i:"",d="nyt-fontHash"+l,s="nyt-fontFace"+l,f=t[i][A],u=localStorage.getItem(d),g=localStorage.getItem(s);if(u===f.hash&&g)o(g);else{var h=function(t,e,n,a,A){return function(){r(t,e,n,a,A)}}(f.url,A,f.hash,d,s);n?h():document.addEventListener("DOMContentLoaded",h)}}};c(e),window.addEventListener("load",function(){c(n,!0)})};;_f.apply(null, [{"shared":{"woff":{"hash":"f2adc73415c5bbb437e993c14559e70e","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/shared-woff.fonts-f2adc73415c5bbb437e993c14559e70e.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"22b34a6a6fd840943496b658184afdd3","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/shared-woff2.fonts-22b34a6a6fd840943496b658184afdd3.css"}},"story":{"woff":{"hash":"3c668927c32fbefb440b4024d5da6351","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/story-woff.fonts-3c668927c32fbefb440b4024d5da6351.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"acec1a902e1795b20a0204af82726cd2","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/story-woff2.fonts-acec1a902e1795b20a0204af82726cd2.css"}},"opinion":{"woff":{"hash":"dfc5106c9c0aaa76688687e664474b04","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/opinion-woff.fonts-dfc5106c9c0aaa76688687e664474b04.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"e2b27ff317927dfd77bdd429409627e0","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/opinion-woff2.fonts-e2b27ff317927dfd77bdd429409627e0.css"}},"tmag":{"woff":{"hash":"4634f3c7ddebb9113b69d4578d9a0ba0","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/tmag-woff.fonts-4634f3c7ddebb9113b69d4578d9a0ba0.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"8622c93c260fa93b229b7249df708fb1","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/tmag-woff2.fonts-8622c93c260fa93b229b7249df708fb1.css"}},"mag":{"woff":{"hash":"109e6d301ed49c8078086b5892696adf","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/mag-woff.fonts-109e6d301ed49c8078086b5892696adf.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"fb42c728dc70cc4ef6010a60cb10b0bd","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/mag-woff2.fonts-fb42c728dc70cc4ef6010a60cb10b0bd.css"}},"well":{"woff":{"hash":"f0e613b89006e99b4622d88aa5563a81","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/well-woff.fonts-f0e613b89006e99b4622d88aa5563a81.css"},"woff2":{"hash":"77806b85de524283fe742b916c9d0ee4","url":"/vi-assets/static-assets/well-woff2.fonts-77806b85de524283fe742b916c9d0ee4.css"}}},["shared","story","well","opinion","tmag","mag"],[]]); })();;(function () { function swgDataLayer(e){return!!window.dataLayer&&((window.dataLayer=window.dataLayer||[]).push({event:"impression",module:e}),!0)}function checkSwgOptOut(){if(!window.localStorage)return!1;var e=window.localStorage.getItem("nyt-swgOptOut");if(!e)return!1;var t=parseInt(e,10);return((new Date).getTime()-t)/864e5<1||(window.localStorage.removeItem("nyt-swgOptOut"),!1)}function swgDeferredAccount(e,t){return e.completeDeferredAccountCreation({entitlements:t,consent:!1}).then(function(e){var t=vi.env.AUTH_HOST+"/svc/account/auth/v1/swg-dal-web",n=e.purchaseData.raw.data?e.purchaseData.raw.data:e.purchaseData.raw,o=JSON.parse(n),a={package_name:o.packageName,product_id:o.productId,purchase_token:o.purchaseToken,google_id_token:e.userData.idToken,google_user_email:e.userData.email,google_user_id:e.userData.id,google_user_name:e.userData.name},r=new XMLHttpRequest;r.withCredentials=!0,r.open("POST",t,!0),r.setRequestHeader("Content-Type","application/json"),r.send(JSON.stringify(a)),r.onload=function(){200===r.status?(swgDataLayer({name:"swg",context:"Deferred",label:"Seamless Signin",region:"swg-modal"}),e.complete().then(function(){window.location.reload(!0)})):(e.complete(),window.location=encodeURI(vi.env.AUTH_HOST+"/get-started/swg-link?redirect="+window.location.href))}}).catch(function(){return!!window.localStorage&&(!window.localStorage.getItem("nyt-swgOptOut")&&(window.localStorage.setItem("nyt-swgOptOut",(new Date).getTime()),!0))}),!0}function loginWithGoogle(){return"undefined"!=typeof window&&(-1===document.cookie.indexOf("NYT-S")&&(!0!==checkSwgOptOut()&&(!!window.SWG&&((window.SWG=window.SWG||[]).push(function(e){return e.init(vi.env.SWG_PUBLICATION_ID),e.getEntitlements().then(function(t){if(void 0===t||!t.raw)return!1;var n={entitlements_token:t.raw};return window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.withCredentials=!0,window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.open("POST",vi.env.AUTH_HOST+"/svc/account/auth/v1/login-swg-web",!0),window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.setRequestHeader("Content-Type","application/json"),window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.send(JSON.stringify(n)),window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.onload=function(){switch(window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.status){case 200:return swgDataLayer({name:"swg",context:"Seamless",label:"Seamless Signin",region:"login"}),window.location.reload(!0),!0;case 412:return swgDeferredAccount(e,t);default:return!1}},t}).catch(function(){return!1}),!0}),!0))))}var _f=function(){if(window.swgUserInfoXhrObject.checkSwgResponse=!1,-1===document.cookie.indexOf("NYT-S")){var e=document.createElement("script");e.src="https://news.google.com/swg/js/v1/swg.js",e.setAttribute("subscriptions-control","manual"),e.setAttribute("async",!0),e.onload=function(){loginWithGoogle()},document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(e)}};;_f.apply(null, []); })();
</script>
<link rel="stylesheet" href="/vi-assets/static-assets/global-42db6c8821fec0e2b3837b2ea2ece8fe.css" />
<style>.css-nuvmzp{font-size:14.25px;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-weight:700;text-transform:uppercase;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.7px;-moz-letter-spacing:0.7px;-ms-letter-spacing:0.7px;letter-spacing:0.7px;line-height:19px;}.css-nuvmzp:hover{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}.css-1gz70xg{border-left:1px solid #ccc;color:#326891;height:12px;margin-left:8px;padding-left:8px;}.css-9e9ivx{display:none;font-size:10px;margin-left:auto;text-transform:uppercase;}.hasLinks .css-9e9ivx{display:block;}@media (min-width:740px){.hasLinks .css-9e9ivx{margin:none;position:absolute;right:20px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.hasLinks .css-9e9ivx{display:none;}}.css-2bwtzy{display:inline-block;padding:6px 4px 4px;margin-bottom:12px;font-size:12px;border-radius:3px;-webkit-transition:background 0.6s ease;transition:background 0.6s ease;}.css-2bwtzy:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}.css-6n7j50{display:inline;}.css-1kj7lfb{display:none;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1kj7lfb{display:inline-block;margin-right:7px;}}.css-10m9xeu{display:block;width:16px;height:16px;}.css-vz7hjd{border:0;-webkit-clip:rect(0 0 0 0);clip:rect(0 0 0 0);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px;}.css-1fe7a5q{display:inline-block;height:16px;vertical-align:sub;width:16px;}.css-1rn5q1r{border:0;-webkit-clip:rect(0 0 0 0);clip:rect(0 0 0 0);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px;border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;background-color:transparent;color:#000;font-size:11px;font-weight:700;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;padding:7px 9px 9px;background:#fff;display:inline-block;left:44px;text-transform:uppercase;-webkit-transition:none;transition:none;}.css-1rn5q1r:active,.css-1rn5q1r:focus{-webkit-clip:auto;clip:auto;overflow:visible;width:auto;height:auto;}.css-1rn5q1r::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-1rn5q1r:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-1rn5q1r:disabled,.css-1rn5q1r.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}.css-1rn5q1r:active,.css-1rn5q1r.active{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1rn5q1r:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}}.css-1rn5q1r:focus{margin-top:3px;padding:8px 8px 6px;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1rn5q1r{left:112px;}}.css-10488qs{display:none;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-10488qs{display:inline-block;position:relative;}}.css-1iruc8t{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0;}.css-1ropbjl::before{background-color:$white;border-bottom:1px solid #e2e2e2;border-top:2px solid #e2e2e2;content:'';display:block;height:1px;margin-top:0;}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-1ropbjl{margin:0 auto;max-width:1200px;padding:0 3% 9px;}}.NYTApp .css-1ropbjl{display:none;}@media print{.css-1ropbjl{display:none;}}.css-uw59u{padding:0 20px;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-uw59u{padding:0 3%;}}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-uw59u{padding:0;}}.css-jxzr5i{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-flex-flow:row;-ms-flex-flow:row;flex-flow:row;}.css-oylsik{display:block;height:44px;vertical-align:middle;width:184px;}.css-1otr2jl{margin:18px 0 0 auto;}.css-1c8n994{color:#6288a5;font-family:nyt-franklin;font-size:11px;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;line-height:11px;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-qtw155{display:block;}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-qtw155{display:none;}}.css-v0l3hm{display:none;}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-v0l3hm{display:block;}}.css-g4gku8{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;margin-top:10px;min-width:600px;}.css-1rr4qq7{-webkit-flex:1;-ms-flex:1;flex:1;}.css-6xhk3s{border-left:1px solid #e2e2e2;-webkit-flex:1;-ms-flex:1;flex:1;padding-left:15px;}.css-rxqrcl{color:#333;font-size:13px;font-weight:700;font-family:nyt-franklin;height:25px;line-height:15px;margin:0;text-transform:uppercase;width:150px;}.css-tj0ten{margin-bottom:5px;white-space:nowrap;}.css-tj0ten:last-child{margin-bottom:10px;}.css-ist4u3.desktop{display:none;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-ist4u3.desktop{display:block;}.css-ist4u3.smartphone{display:none;}}.css-1gprdgz{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0;-webkit-columns:2;columns:2;padding:0 0 15px;}.css-10t7hia{height:34px;line-height:34px;list-style-type:none;}.css-10t7hia.desktop{display:none;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-10t7hia.desktop{display:block;}.css-10t7hia.smartphone{display:none;}}.css-mzqdl{color:#333;display:block;font-family:nyt-franklin;font-size:15px;font-weight:500;height:34px;line-height:34px;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:capitalize;}.css-kwpx34{color:#000;display:inline-block;font-family:nyt-franklin;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:capitalize;width:150px;font-size:14px;font-weight:500;height:23px;line-height:16px;}.css-kwpx34:hover{cursor:pointer;-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}body.dark .css-kwpx34{color:#fff;}.css-1k2cjfc{color:#000;display:inline-block;font-family:nyt-franklin;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:capitalize;width:150px;font-size:16px;font-weight:700;height:25px;line-height:15px;padding-bottom:0;}.css-1k2cjfc:hover{cursor:pointer;-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}body.dark .css-1k2cjfc{color:#fff;}.css-1vhk1ks{color:#000;display:inline-block;font-family:nyt-franklin;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:capitalize;width:150px;font-size:11px;font-weight:500;height:23px;line-height:21px;}.css-1vhk1ks:hover{cursor:pointer;-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}body.dark .css-1vhk1ks{color:#fff;}.css-6td9kr{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0;border-top:1px solid #e2e2e2;margin-top:2px;padding-top:10px;}.css-r5ic95{display:inline-block;height:13px;width:13px;margin-right:7px;vertical-align:middle;}.css-15uy5yv{border-top:1px solid #ebebeb;padding-top:9px;}.css-1p8nkc0{color:#999;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;padding:10px 0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;white-space:nowrap;}.css-1p8nkc0:hover{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}.css-1hyfx7x{display:none;}@-webkit-keyframes animation-5j8bii{from{opacity:0;}to{opacity:1;}}@keyframes animation-5j8bii{from{opacity:0;}to{opacity:1;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1am0aiv{from{visibility:visible;opacity:1;}to{visibility:visible;opacity:0;}}@keyframes animation-1am0aiv{from{visibility:visible;opacity:1;}to{visibility:visible;opacity:0;}}.css-17ih8de{box-sizing:border-box;vertical-align:top;}.css-8atqhb{width:100%;}.css-k2fwhk{color:#ccc;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-size:0.5625rem;font-weight:400;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.05rem;-moz-letter-spacing:0.05rem;-ms-letter-spacing:0.05rem;letter-spacing:0.05rem;line-height:0.5625rem;margin-bottom:9px;text-align:center;text-transform:uppercase;}.css-1157aqr{margin:2rem auto;max-width:1200;text-align:center;background-color:#f7f7f7;padding-bottom:30px;padding-top:15px;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1157aqr{width:calc(10 * (((100vw - 205px) - 15px) / 12) + (10 - 1) * 15px);}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1157aqr{border-top:1px solid #ebebeb;border-bottom:1px solid #ebebeb;width:calc(12 * (((100vw - 370px) - 15px) / 12) + (12 - 1) * 30px);}}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-1157aqr{width:calc(20 * (((100vw - 730px) - 15px) / 24) + (20 - 1) * 30px);}}@media print{.css-1157aqr{display:none;}}.css-y8aj3r{padding:0;}.css-60hakz{color:#999;display:inline;margin-right:16px;padding:10px 0;width:100%;}.css-60hakz a{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (max-width:659px){.css-60hakz:nth-of-type(3),.css-60hakz:nth-of-type(4){display:none;}}.css-60hakz:last-of-type{margin-right:0;}.css-1baulvz{display:inline-block;}.css-i29ckm{width:calc(100% - 40px);max-width:600px;margin:1.5rem auto 2rem;}@media (min-width:1440px){.css-i29ckm{width:600px;max-width:600px;}}@media (min-width:600px){.css-i29ckm{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-webkit-justify-content:space-between;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between;-webkit-align-items:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;}}@media (max-width:600px){.css-i29ckm .facebook,.css-i29ckm .twitter,.css-i29ckm .email{display:inline-block;}}.css-1vegfwe{width:calc(100% - 40px);max-width:600px;margin-left:20px;margin-bottom:1.375rem;color:#333;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:start;-webkit-justify-content:start;-ms-flex-pack:start;justify-content:start;-webkit-flex-direction:column;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;text-align:left;}.css-1vegfwe .e16638kd0{font-size:0.8125rem;line-height:1.125rem;}.css-1vegfwe .e1n4ps4i0{font-weight:600;font-size:0.875rem;line-height:1.125rem;}.css-1vegfwe .e1n4ps4i0 span{white-space:nowrap;display:inline;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1vegfwe{max-width:720px;margin-left:auto;margin-bottom:1.5rem;text-align:center;}}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1vegfwe{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;-webkit-flex-direction:row;-ms-flex-direction:row;flex-direction:row;}}.css-dehhk5{max-width:600px;width:100%;margin:0 auto 1.375rem;text-align:left;width:calc(100% - 40px);max-width:600px;margin-left:20px;margin-right:20px;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-dehhk5{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-dehhk5{text-align:center;margin-bottom:1.5rem;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-f8wsfj{0%{opacity:1;}50%{opacity:0;}100%{opacity:0;}}@keyframes animation-f8wsfj{0%{opacity:1;}50%{opacity:0;}100%{opacity:0;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-mhvv8m{0%{opacity:0;}50%{opacity:0;}100%{opacity:1;}}@keyframes animation-mhvv8m{0%{opacity:0;}50%{opacity:0;}100%{opacity:1;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-m6999o{100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);-ms-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg);-webkit-transform-origin:center;-ms-transform-origin:center;transform-origin:center;}}@keyframes animation-m6999o{100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);-ms-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg);-webkit-transform-origin:center;-ms-transform-origin:center;transform-origin:center;}}.css-cfo9c3{display:block;height:5px;}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1m9j9gf{from{background-color:#f7f7f5;}to{background-color:transparent;}}@keyframes animation-1m9j9gf{from{background-color:#f7f7f5;}to{background-color:transparent;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1q1yk17{to{width:11px;}}@keyframes animation-1q1yk17{to{width:11px;}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-g7rb99{0%{-webkit-transform:scale(1) rotate(0);-ms-transform:scale(1) rotate(0);transform:scale(1) rotate(0);}100%{-webkit-transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);-ms-transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);}}@keyframes animation-g7rb99{0%{-webkit-transform:scale(1) rotate(0);-ms-transform:scale(1) rotate(0);transform:scale(1) rotate(0);}100%{-webkit-transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);-ms-transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);transform:scale(1.05) rotate(-90deg);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-ghw4n2{0%{opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(100px);-ms-transform:translateY(100px);transform:translateY(100px);}100%{opacity:1;-webkit-transform:translateY(0);-ms-transform:translateY(0);transform:translateY(0);}}@keyframes animation-ghw4n2{0%{opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(100px);-ms-transform:translateY(100px);transform:translateY(100px);}100%{opacity:1;-webkit-transform:translateY(0);-ms-transform:translateY(0);transform:translateY(0);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1c5cfvc{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-1c5cfvc{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(0px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-htgkrt{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-htgkrt{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-e64et{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-e64et{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-9zaqp9{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}}@keyframes animation-9zaqp9{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-16fq4rz{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-16fq4rz{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1kjk1j2{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}}@keyframes animation-1kjk1j2{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-88g286{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}}@keyframes animation-88g286{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,5px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-12yx39b{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-12yx39b{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}25%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);}50%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}75%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,1) translate(-34px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.95) translate(-34px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-4hu8jm{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-4hu8jm{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(0px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(0px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);transform:translate(0px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(0px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1wqz2f4{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@keyframes animation-1wqz2f4{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-yl3z84{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-yl3z84{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1q3gjvc{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@keyframes animation-1q3gjvc{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(-11.329999923706055px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-nc39ev{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-nc39ev{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-amd09y{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@keyframes animation-amd09y{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(-22.670000076293945px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-ru1vxe{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@keyframes animation-ru1vxe{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,15px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,10px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);transform:translate(34px,0px) translate(-34px,0px) translate(0px,30px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-ajnadh{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);}}@keyframes animation-ajnadh{0%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.85) translate(-34px,0px);}33.33%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.9) translate(-34px,0px);}100%{-webkit-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);-ms-transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);transform:translate(34px,0px) scale(1,0.1) translate(-34px,0px);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-b7n1on{0%{-webkit-transform:rotate(0deg);-ms-transform:rotate(0deg);transform:rotate(0deg);}100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);-ms-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg);}}@keyframes animation-b7n1on{0%{-webkit-transform:rotate(0deg);-ms-transform:rotate(0deg);transform:rotate(0deg);}100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(360deg);-ms-transform:rotate(360deg);transform:rotate(360deg);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1b9egsl{0%{-webkit-transform:rotate(20deg);-ms-transform:rotate(20deg);transform:rotate(20deg);}100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(380deg);-ms-transform:rotate(380deg);transform:rotate(380deg);}}@keyframes animation-1b9egsl{0%{-webkit-transform:rotate(20deg);-ms-transform:rotate(20deg);transform:rotate(20deg);}100%{-webkit-transform:rotate(380deg);-ms-transform:rotate(380deg);transform:rotate(380deg);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-1egl8em{from{opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);-ms-transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);}to{opacity:1;-webkit-transform:translate3d(0,0,0);-ms-transform:translate3d(0,0,0);transform:translate3d(0,0,0);}}@keyframes animation-1egl8em{from{opacity:0;-webkit-transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);-ms-transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);transform:translate3d(0,13%,0);}to{opacity:1;-webkit-transform:translate3d(0,0,0);-ms-transform:translate3d(0,0,0);transform:translate3d(0,0,0);}}@-webkit-keyframes animation-7y3qfv{0%{opacity:0;}10%,90%{opacity:1;}100%{opacity:0;}}@keyframes animation-7y3qfv{0%{opacity:0;}10%,90%{opacity:1;}100%{opacity:0;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1bymuyk{position:relative;border-bottom:1px solid #e2e2e2;}}.css-1waixk9{background:#fff;border-bottom:1px solid #e2e2e2;height:36px;padding:8px 15px 3px;position:relative;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1waixk9{background:#fff;padding:10px 15px 6px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1waixk9{background:transparent;border-bottom:0;padding:4px 15px 2px;}}@media print{.css-1waixk9{background:transparent;}}@media (min-width:740px){}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1waixk9{margin:0 auto;max-width:1605px;}}.css-1f7ibof{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:space-around;-webkit-justify-content:space-around;-ms-flex-pack:space-around;justify-content:space-around;left:10px;position:absolute;}@media (min-width:1024px){}@media print{.css-1f7ibof{display:none;}}.css-l2ztic{border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;background-color:transparent;color:#000;font-size:11px;font-weight:700;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;padding:7px 9px 9px;border:0;padding:8px 9px;text-transform:uppercase;}.css-l2ztic.hidden{opacity:0;visibility:hidden;}.css-l2ztic.hidden:focus{opacity:1;}.css-l2ztic::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-l2ztic:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-l2ztic:disabled,.css-l2ztic.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}.css-l2ztic:active,.css-l2ztic.active{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-l2ztic:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-l2ztic{display:none;}}.css-19lv58h{border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;-webkit-appearance:button;-moz-appearance:button;appearance:button;background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #ebebeb;color:#333;display:inline-block;font-size:11px;font-weight:500;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;line-height:13px;margin:0;padding:8px 9px;text-transform:uppercase;vertical-align:middle;display:none;}.css-19lv58h::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-19lv58h:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-19lv58h:disabled,.css-19lv58h.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}.css-19lv58h:active,.css-19lv58h.active{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-19lv58h:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-19lv58h{border:0;display:inline-block;margin-right:8px;}}.css-mgtjo2{border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;background-color:transparent;color:#000;font-size:11px;font-weight:700;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;padding:7px 9px 9px;border:0;}.css-mgtjo2::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-mgtjo2:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-mgtjo2:disabled,.css-mgtjo2.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}.css-mgtjo2:active,.css-mgtjo2.active{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-mgtjo2:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}}.css-mgtjo2.activeSearchButton{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-mgtjo2{padding:8px 9px 9px;}}.css-1wr3we4{display:none;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1wr3we4{display:block;position:absolute;left:105px;line-height:19px;top:10px;}}.css-10698na{text-align:center;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-10698na{padding-top:0;}}@media (min-width:1024px){}@media print{.css-10698na a[href]::after{content:'';}.css-10698na svg{fill:black;}}.css-nhjhh0{display:block;width:189px;height:26px;margin:5px auto 0;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-nhjhh0{width:225px;height:31px;margin:4px auto 0;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-nhjhh0{width:195px;height:26px;margin:6px auto 0;}}.css-y3sf94{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-box-pack:space-around;-webkit-justify-content:space-around;-ms-flex-pack:space-around;justify-content:space-around;position:absolute;right:10px;top:9px;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-y3sf94{top:4px;}}@media print{.css-y3sf94{display:none;}}.css-1bnxwmn{border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;background-color:#6288a5;border:1px solid #326891;color:#fff;font-size:11px;font-weight:700;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.05em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.05em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.05em;letter-spacing:0.05em;line-height:11px;padding:8px 9px 6px;text-transform:uppercase;}.css-1bnxwmn::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-1bnxwmn:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-1bnxwmn:disabled,.css-1bnxwmn.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1bnxwmn:hover{background-color:#326891;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1bnxwmn{padding:11px 12px 8px;}}.css-1bnxwmn:hover{border:1px solid #326891;}.css-1i8g3m4{border-radius:3px;cursor:pointer;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;-webkit-transition:ease 0.6s;transition:ease 0.6s;background-color:transparent;color:#000;font-size:11px;font-weight:700;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;padding:7px 9px 9px;border:0;display:block;}.css-1i8g3m4.hidden{opacity:0;visibility:hidden;}.css-1i8g3m4.hidden:focus{opacity:1;}.css-1i8g3m4::-moz-focus-inner{padding:0;border:0;}.css-1i8g3m4:-moz-focusring{outline:1px dotted;}.css-1i8g3m4:disabled,.css-1i8g3m4.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:default;}.css-1i8g3m4:active,.css-1i8g3m4.active{background-color:#f7f7f7;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1i8g3m4:hover{background-color:#f7f7f7;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1i8g3m4{border:none;line-height:13px;padding:9px 9px 12px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1i8g3m4{display:none;}}@media (min-width:1150px){}.css-15hmgas{-webkit-align-items:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-size:11px;-webkit-box-pack:space-around;-webkit-justify-content:space-around;-ms-flex-pack:space-around;justify-content:space-around;padding:13px 20px 12px;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-15hmgas{position:relative;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-15hmgas{-webkit-box-pack:justify;-webkit-justify-content:space-between;-ms-flex-pack:justify;justify-content:space-between;border:none;padding:0;height:0;-webkit-transform:translateY(42px);-ms-transform:translateY(42px);transform:translateY(42px);}}@media print{.css-15hmgas{display:none;}}.css-uqyvli{color:#121212;font-size:13px;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;display:none;width:auto;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-uqyvli{text-align:center;width:100%;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-uqyvli{font-size:12px;margin-bottom:10px;width:auto;}}.css-1uqjmks{color:#121212;font-size:12px;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-weight:500;display:none;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1uqjmks{margin:0;position:absolute;left:20px;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;top:0;bottom:0;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1uqjmks{display:none;}}.css-1bvtpon{display:none;}@media (min-width:1024px){}.css-16ogagc{background:transparent;display:inline-block;height:20px;width:20px;background-color:#eee;border:1px #eee solid;border-radius:100%;padding:5px;width:27px;height:27px;}.css-16ogagc.hidden{opacity:0;visibility:hidden;}.css-16ogagc.hidden:focus{opacity:1;}.css-16ogagc:hover{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #ccc;}.css-4brsb6{display:inline-block;height:15px;vertical-align:middle;width:15px;background-color:#eee;border:1px #eee solid;border-radius:100%;padding:5px;width:15px;height:15px;}.css-4brsb6.facebook{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-fb-circle-2ec7780140bd9e8e8398bbcdf5661569.svg);}.css-4brsb6.twitter{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-twitter-circle-fc7c2748f5613c68963a0df203bffc05.svg);}.css-4brsb6.email{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-email-circle-a2acce7e23b21d47bb606b628a6c7e34.svg);}.css-4brsb6.link{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-permalink-circle-3ff3876a106221ee493d9542c0895863.svg);}.css-4brsb6.linkedin{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-linkedin-circle-4d7bcf236c5f3a086738746f41f46f7b.svg);}.css-4brsb6.whatsapp{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-whatsapp-video-a9503bf2b3c73111106c496d3ebc8c67.svg);}.css-4brsb6.reddit{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-reddit-f882338200fd1971b767627fa5f60124.svg);}.css-4brsb6:hover{background-color:#fff;border:1px solid #ccc;}.css-uhuo44{display:inline-block;height:15px;vertical-align:middle;width:15px;bottom:5px;position:relative;width:15px;height:15px;bottom:4px;}.css-uhuo44.facebook{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-fb-circle-2ec7780140bd9e8e8398bbcdf5661569.svg);}.css-uhuo44.twitter{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-twitter-circle-fc7c2748f5613c68963a0df203bffc05.svg);}.css-uhuo44.email{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-email-circle-a2acce7e23b21d47bb606b628a6c7e34.svg);}.css-uhuo44.link{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-permalink-circle-3ff3876a106221ee493d9542c0895863.svg);}.css-uhuo44.linkedin{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-linkedin-circle-4d7bcf236c5f3a086738746f41f46f7b.svg);}.css-uhuo44.whatsapp{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-whatsapp-video-a9503bf2b3c73111106c496d3ebc8c67.svg);}.css-uhuo44.reddit{background-image:url(/vi-assets/static-assets/icon-share-reddit-f882338200fd1971b767627fa5f60124.svg);}.css-ar1l6a{color:#999;display:inline;margin-right:16px;padding:10px 0;width:100%;}.css-ar1l6a a{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (max-width:659px){.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(3),.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(4){display:none;}}.css-ar1l6a:last-of-type{margin-right:0;}.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(1),.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(2),.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(3),.css-ar1l6a:nth-of-type(4){display:inline;}.css-mn5hq9{cursor:pointer;margin:0;border-top:1px solid #ebebeb;color:#333;font-family:nyt-franklin;font-size:13px;font-weight:700;height:44px;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.04rem;-moz-letter-spacing:0.04rem;-ms-letter-spacing:0.04rem;letter-spacing:0.04rem;line-height:44px;text-transform:uppercase;}.accordionExpanded .css-mn5hq9{color:#b3b3b3;}.css-1qmnftd{font-size:11px;text-align:center;}@media (max-width:600px){.css-1qmnftd{padding-bottom:25px;}}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1qmnftd{padding-bottom:25px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1qmnftd{padding:0 3% 9px;}}@media (min-width:1150px){.css-1qmnftd{margin:0 auto;max-width:1200px;}}.NYTApp .css-1qmnftd{display:none;}@media print{.css-1qmnftd{display:none;}}.css-1ho5u4o{list-style:none;margin:0 0 15px;padding:0;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1ho5u4o{display:inline-block;}}.css-13o0c9t{list-style:none;line-height:8px;margin:0 0 35px;padding:0;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-13o0c9t{display:inline-block;}}.css-1yo489b{display:inline-block;line-height:20px;padding:0 10px;}.css-1yo489b:first-child{border-left:none;}.css-1yo489b.desktop{display:none;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1yo489b.smartphone{display:none;}.css-1yo489b.desktop{display:inline-block;}}.css-1s4ffep{color:#121212;font-family:nyt-cheltenham,georgia,'times new roman',times,serif;font-weight:700;font-style:italic;font-size:1.9375rem;line-height:2.25rem;text-align:left;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1s4ffep{font-size:2.5rem;line-height:3rem;}}.css-1riqqik{display:inline;color:#333;}.css-1riqqik span{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;-webkit-text-decoration-color:#ccc;text-decoration-color:#ccc;}.css-1riqqik span:hover,.css-1riqqik span:focus{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-o15hd4{font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-weight:500;color:#333;margin-bottom:1rem;font-size:0.8125rem;line-height:1rem;}.css-brak7x{color:#999;display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-flex-shrink:0;-ms-flex-negative:0;flex-shrink:0;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-size:17px;margin-bottom:5px;}@media print{.css-brak7x{display:none;}}.css-brak7x li:nth-of-type(3),.css-brak7x li:nth-of-type(4){display:inline;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-brak7x{-webkit-box-pack:center;-webkit-justify-content:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;}}@media print{.css-jqthw3{margin-bottom:15px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-jqthw3{position:fixed;width:100%;top:0;left:0;z-index:200;background-color:#fff;border-bottom:none;-webkit-transition:all 0.2s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.2s ease-in-out;}}.NYTApp .css-jqthw3{display:none;}.css-n4ogti{margin-top:0px;width:100%;}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-n4ogti{margin-top:43px;}}.css-rqw92o{background-color:#f7f7f7;border-bottom:1px solid #f3f3f3;display:block;padding-bottom:15px;padding-top:10px;margin:0;min-height:90px;display:none;}@media (max-width:765px){.css-rqw92o{display:none;}}@media (min-width:765px){.css-rqw92o{display:block;margin-bottom:30px;min-height:90px;}}@media print{.css-rqw92o{display:none;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{margin-top:1.875rem;color:#121212;font-weight:700;line-height:0.75rem;margin-bottom:0.625rem;}@media print{.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{margin-left:0;margin-right:0;width:100%;max-width:100%;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e1h9rw200{margin-bottom:1rem;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1p8vgzh .e1h9rw200{position:relative;}}.css-1p8vgzh .ezdmqqa0{margin-bottom:3px;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh .ezdmqqa0{margin-bottom:0px;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e1wiw3jv0{color:#333;}.css-1p8vgzh .e16638kd0{display:inline-block;}.css-1p8vgzh .e12qa4dv0{margin-bottom:20px;color:#121212;}@media print{.css-1p8vgzh .e12qa4dv0{margin-left:0;margin-right:0;width:100%;max-width:100%;}}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh{margin-top:45px;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{font-size:0.75rem;line-height:0.875rem;color:#121212;margin-top:20px;margin-bottom:10px;text-align:center;width:calc(100% - 40px);max-width:600px;margin-left:20px;margin-right:20px;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{font-size:0.875rem;line-height:1.125rem;margin-top:35px;}}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{width:600px;}}@media (min-width:1440px){.css-1p8vgzh .e6idgb70{width:600px;max-width:600px;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e1h9rw200{font-size:1.8125rem;line-height:2.0625rem;margin-bottom:1.125rem;text-align:left;width:calc(100% - 40px);max-width:600px;margin-left:20px;margin-right:20px;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh .e1h9rw200{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1p8vgzh .e1h9rw200{width:720px;max-width:720px;font-size:2.5rem;line-height:2.75rem;text-align:center;margin-bottom:1.25rem;}}.css-1p8vgzh .e16638kd0{text-transform:capitalize;}.css-1p8vgzh .e16638kd0 span:last-of-type{margin-right:0;}@media (min-width:600px){.css-1p8vgzh .e16638kd0{margin-top:0px;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1p8vgzh .e16638kd0{margin-right:auto;}}.css-1c5207x{display:inline-block;-webkit-letter-spacing:0.02em;-moz-letter-spacing:0.02em;-ms-letter-spacing:0.02em;letter-spacing:0.02em;font-size:0.875rem;line-height:1.125rem;margin:0;font-family:nyt-franklin,helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-weight:700;color:#333;}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1c5207x{font-size:0.9375rem;line-height:1.25rem;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1c5207x{margin-left:auto;}}@media (min-width:740px){.css-1c5207x{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}}.css-1c5207x .last-byline{padding-right:10px;}.css-15n42zn{width:100%;margin:0 auto;height:auto;max-width:1600px;min-width:300px;margin:1.5rem auto;max-width:1600px;min-width:300px;width:calc(100% - 20px);}@media (min-width:340px) and (max-width:630px){.css-15n42zn{width:calc(100% - 40px);}}</style>
<style>[data-timezone] { display: none }</style>
<script id="adslot-config">
var AdSlot4=function(){"use strict";function b(n,i,t){var o=document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0],e=document.createElement("script");i&&(e.onload=i),t&&(e.onerror=t),e.src=n,e.async=!0,o.appendChild(e)}function z(n){var i=document.cookie.match(new RegExp("".concat(n,"=([^;]+)")));return i?i[1]:""}return function(){var B=window.AdSlot4||{};B.cmd=B.cmd||[];var x=!1;if(B.loadScripts)return B;function A(o){"art, oak"!==o&&"art,oak"!==o||(o="art"),B.cmd.push(function(){B.events.subscribe({name:"AdDefined",scope:"all",callback:function(n){var t,i=[-1];n.sizes.forEach(function(n){n[0]<window.innerWidth&&n[0]>i[0]&&(i=[]).push(n)}),i[0][1]&&window.apstag.fetchBids({slots:[{slotID:n.id,slotName:"".concat(n.id,"_").concat(o,"_web"),sizes:(t=i[0][1],Array.isArray(t)?[[300,250],[728,90],[970,90],[970,250]].filter(function(i){return t.some(function(n){return n[0]===i[0]&&n[1]===i[1]})}):(console.warn("filterSizes() did not receive an array"),[]))}]},function(){window.googletag.cmd.push(function(){window.apstag.setDisplayBids()})})}})})}return B.loadScripts=function(n){var i,t,o,e,d,a,c=n||{},s=c.loadMnet,r=void 0===s||s,u=c.loadAmazon,w=void 0===u||u,p=c.loadBait,l=void 0===p||p,f=c.section,m=void 0===f?"none":f,v=c.pageViewId,g=void 0===v?"":v,h=c.pageType,y=void 0===h?"":h;x||(!("1"===z("nyt-gdpr")||(i=document.referrer||"",(t=/([a-zA-Z0-9_\-.]+)(@|%40)([a-zA-Z0-9_\-.]+).([a-zA-Z]{2,5})/).test(i)||t.test(window.location.href))||"s"===z("nyt-purr").substring(1,2))&&(!r||window.advBidxc&&window.advBidxc.isLoaded||(d=g,a="8CU2553YN",window.innerWidth<740&&(a="8CULO58R6"),b("https://contextual.media.net/bidexchange.js?cid=".concat(a,"&dn=").concat("www.nytimes.com","&https=1"),function(){window.advBidxc&&window.advBidxc.isLoaded||console.warn("Media.net not loading properly")},function(){B.cmd.push(function(){B.events.publish({name:"BidderError",value:{type:"Mnet"}})})}),window.advBidxc=window.advBidxc||{},window.advBidxc.renderAd=function(){},window.advBidxc.startTime=(new Date).getTime(),window.advBidxc.customerId={mediaNetCID:a},window.advBidxc.misc={isGptDisabled:1},d&&(window.advBidxc.misc.keywords=d)),w&&!window.apstag&&(o=m,e=y,function(t,o){function n(n,i){o[t]._Q.push([n,i])}o[t]||(o[t]={init:function(){n("i",arguments)},fetchBids:function(){n("f",arguments)},setDisplayBids:function(){},targetingKeys:function(){return[]},_Q:[]})}("apstag",window),b("//c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js",function(){window.apstag||console.warn("A9 not loading properly")},function(){B.cmd.push(function(){B.events.publish({name:"BidderError",value:{type:"A9"}})})}),window.apstag.init({pubID:"3030",adServer:"googletag",params:{si_section:o}}),A(e))),l&&b("https://nytimes.com/ads/google/adsbygoogle.js",function(){},function(){B.cmd.push(function(){B.events.publish({name:"AdEmpty",value:{type:"AdBlockOn"}})})}),x=!0)},window.AdSlot4=B}()}();
AdSlot4.loadScripts({
loadMnet: window.NYTD.Abra('medianet_toggle') !== '1_block',
loadAmazon: window.NYTD.Abra('amazon_toggle') !== '1_block',
section: 'us',
pageType: 'int',
pageViewId: window.NYTD.PageViewId.current,
});
(function () { var _f=function(e){var o=performance.navigation&&1===performance.navigation.type;function t(){return window.matchMedia("(max-width: 739px)").matches}function n(e){var n,r,i,d,a,p,s=function(){var e=window.userXhrObject&&""!==window.userXhrObject.responseText&&JSON.parse(window.userXhrObject.responseText).data||null,o=null;return e&&e.user&&e.user.userInfo&&(o=e.user.userInfo.demographics),o}();return s?(r=e,d=(n=s)&&n.emailSubscriptions,(a=n&&n.bundleSubscriptions)&&r&&(r.sub="reg",d&&d.length&&(r.em=d.toString().toLowerCase()),n.wat&&(r.wat=n.wat.toLowerCase()),a&&a.length&&a[0].bundle&&(i=a[0],r.sub=i.bundle.toLowerCase(),i.source&&(r.subsrc=i.source.toLowerCase()),i.promotion&&(r.subprm=i.promotion),i.in_grace&&(r.grace=i.in_grace.toString()))),e=r):e.sub="anon",t()?(e.prop="mnyt",e.plat="mweb",e.ver="mvi"):(e.prop="nyt",e.plat="web",e.ver="vi"),"/es/"===window.location.pathname.substring(0,4)&&(e.prop="esnyt",e.edn="es",t()&&(e.prop="mesnyt")),"hp"===e.typ&&(document.referrer&&(e.topref=document.referrer),o&&(e.refresh="manual")),e.abra_dfp=(p=document.documentElement.getAttribute("data-nyt-ab"))?p.split(" ").reduce(function(e,o){var t=o.split("="),n=t[0].toLowerCase(),r=t[1];return(n.indexOf("dfp")>-1||n.indexOf("redbird")>-1)&&e.push(n+"_"+r),e},[]):"",e.page_view_id=window.NYTD.PageViewId&&window.NYTD.PageViewId.current,e}var r=e||{},i=r.adTargeting||{},d=r.adUnitPath||"/29390238/nyt/homepage",a=r.offset||400,p=r.hideTopAd||t(),s=r.lockdownAds||!1,u=r.sizeMapping||{top:[[970,["fluid",[728,90],[970,90],[970,250],[1605,300]]],[728,["fluid",[728,90],[1605,300]]],[0,["fluid",[300,250],[300,420]]]],fp1:[[0,[195,250]]],fp2:[[0,[195,250]]],fp3:[[0,[195,250]]],interstitial:[[0,[[1,1],[640,480]]]],mktg:[[1020,[300,250]],[0,[]]],pencil:[[728,[[336,46]],[0,[]]]],pp_edpick:[[0,["fluid"]]],pp_morein:[[0,["fluid"],[210,218]]],ribbon:[[0,["fluid"]]],sponsor:[[765,[150,50]],[0,[320,25]]],supplemental:[[1020,[[300,250],[300,600]]],[0,[]]],default:[[970,["fluid",[728,90],[970,90],[970,250],[1605,300]]],[728,["fluid",[728,90],[300,250],[1605,300]]],[0,["fluid",[300,250],[300,420]]]]},w=r.dfpToggleName||"dfp_home_toggle";window.AdSlot4=window.AdSlot4||{},window.AdSlot4.cmd=window.AdSlot4.cmd||[],window.AdSlot4.cmd.push(function(){window.AdSlot4.init({adTargeting:n(i),adUnitPath:d,sizeMapping:u,offset:a,haltDFP:"1_block"===window.NYTD.Abra(w),hideTopAd:p,lockdownAds:s}),window.NYTD.Abra.reportExposure("dfp_adslot4v2")})};;_f.apply(null, [{"adTargeting":{"als_test":"1568448529347","prop":"nyt","plat":"web","edn":"us","brandsensitive":"false","org":"democraticparty","des":"presidentialelectionof2020","auth":"aliciaparlapiano,jasmineclee,weiyicai","coll":"election2020,usnews","artlen":"short","ledemedsz":"none","template":"interactive","typ":"int","section":"us","si_section":"us","id":"100000006640050","pt":"nt1,nt11,nt13,nt17,nt5,nt7","gscat":"gs_politics,gs_politics_misc,gs_politics_american,gs_science,famine,gs_science_environ,gs_health_misc,gs_health,neg_fcli,neg_chanel,gv_safe"},"adUnitPath":"/29390238/nyt/us/politics/elections"}]); })();
</script>
</head>
<body>
<div id="app"><div id="standalone-header"><div class="interactive-masthead css-jqthw3 e1suatyy0"><header class="css-1bymuyk e1suatyy1"><section class="css-1waixk9 e1suatyy2"><div class="css-1f7ibof er09x8g0"><div class="css-6n7j50"><button aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="Sections Navigation &amp; Search" class="er09x8g1 css-l2ztic" data-testid="nav-button"><svg class="css-1fe7a5q" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><rect x="1" y="3" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect><rect x="1" y="7" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect><rect x="1" y="11" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect></svg></button></div><button id="desktop-sections-button" aria-label="Sections Navigation" class="css-19lv58h er09x8g2"><span class="css-vz7hjd">Sections</span><svg class="css-1fe7a5q" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><rect x="1" y="3" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect><rect x="1" y="7" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect><rect x="1" y="11" fill="#333333" width="14" height="2"></rect></svg></button><div class="css-10488qs"><button class="css-mgtjo2 ewfai8r0" data-test-id="search-button"><span class="css-vz7hjd">SEARCH</span><svg class="css-1fe7a5q" viewBox="0 0 16 16"><path fill="#333" d="M11.3,9.2C11.7,8.4,12,7.5,12,6.5C12,3.5,9.5,1,6.5,1S1,3.5,1,6.5S3.5,12,6.5,12c1,0,1.9-0.3,2.7-0.7l3.3,3.3c0.3,0.3,0.7,0.4,1.1,0.4s0.8-0.1,1.1-0.4c0.6-0.6,0.6-1.5,0-2.1L11.3,9.2zM6.5,10.3c-2.1,0-3.8-1.7-3.8-3.8c0-2.1,1.7-3.8,3.8-3.8c2.1,0,3.8,1.7,3.8,3.8C10.3,8.6,8.6,10.3,6.5,10.3z"></path></svg></button></div><a class="css-1rn5q1r" href="#site-content">Skip to content</a><a class="css-1rn5q1r" href="#site-index">Skip to site index</a></div><div class="css-1wr3we4 eaxe0e00"><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/2020-election" class="css-nuvmzp">Elections</a></div><div class="css-10698na e1huz5gh0"><a aria-label="New York Times Logo. Click to visit the homepage" class="css-nhjhh0 e1huz5gh1" href="/"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="" viewBox="0 0 184 25" fill="#000"><path d="M13.8 2.9c0-2-1.9-2.5-3.4-2.5v.3c.9 0 1.6.3 1.6 1 0 .4-.3 1-1.2 1-.7 0-2.2-.4-3.3-.8C6.2 1.4 5 1 4 1 2 1 .6 2.5.6 4.2c0 1.5 1.1 2 1.5 2.2l.1-.2c-.2-.2-.5-.4-.5-1 0-.4.4-1.1 1.4-1.1.9 0 2.1.4 3.7.9 1.4.4 2.9.7 3.7.8v3.1L9 10.2v.1l1.5 1.3v4.3c-.8.5-1.7.6-2.5.6-1.5 0-2.8-.4-3.9-1.6l4.1-2V6l-5 2.2C3.6 6.9 4.7 6 5.8 5.4l-.1-.3c-3 .8-5.7 3.6-5.7 7 0 4 3.3 7 7 7 4 0 6.6-3.2 6.6-6.5h-.2c-.6 1.3-1.5 2.5-2.6 3.1v-4.1l1.6-1.3v-.1l-1.6-1.3V5.8c1.5 0 3-1 3-2.9zm-8.7 11l-1.2.6c-.7-.9-1.1-2.1-1.1-3.8 0-.7 0-1.5.2-2.1l2.1-.9v6.2zm10.6 2.3l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.1-.2-.8.5-1-1V9.4l.8-.6 1.7 1.4v6.1c0 3.8-.8 4.4-2.5 5v.3c2.8.1 5.4-.8 5.4-5.7V9.3l.9-.7-.2-.2-.8.6-2.5-2.1L18.5 9V.8h-.2l-3.5 2.4v.2c.4.2 1 .4 1 1.5l-.1 11.3zM34 15.1L31.5 17 29 15v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.6l-1 .8.2.2.9-.7 3.4 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.4zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zM53.1 2c0-.3-.1-.6-.2-.9h-.2c-.3.8-.7 1.2-1.7 1.2-.9 0-1.5-.5-1.9-.9l-2.9 3.3.2.2 1-.9c.6.5 1.1.9 2.5 1v8.3L44 3.2c-.5-.8-1.2-1.9-2.6-1.9-1.6 0-3 1.4-2.8 3.6h.3c.1-.6.4-1.3 1.1-1.3.5 0 1 .5 1.3 1v3.3c-1.8 0-3 .8-3 2.3 0 .8.4 2 1.6 2.3v-.2c-.2-.2-.3-.4-.3-.7 0-.5.4-.9 1.1-.9h.5v4.2c-2.1 0-3.8 1.2-3.8 3.2 0 1.9 1.6 2.8 3.4 2.7v-.2c-1.1-.1-1.6-.6-1.6-1.3 0-.9.6-1.3 1.4-1.3.8 0 1.5.5 2 1.1l2.9-3.2-.2-.2-.7.8c-1.1-1-1.7-1.3-3-1.5V5l8 14h.6V5c1.5-.1 2.9-1.3 2.9-3zm7.3 13.1L57.9 17l-2.5-2v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.6l-1 .8.2.2.9-.7 3.4 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.4zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zM76.7 8l-.7.5-1.9-1.6-2.2 2 .9.9v7.5l-2.4-1.5V9.6l.8-.5-2.3-2.2-2.2 2 .9.9V17l-.3.2-2.1-1.5v-6c0-1.4-.7-1.8-1.5-2.3-.7-.5-1.1-.8-1.1-1.5 0-.6.6-.9.9-1.1v-.2c-.8 0-2.9.8-2.9 2.7 0 1 .5 1.4 1 1.9s1 .9 1 1.8v5.8l-1.1.8.2.2 1-.8 2.3 2 2.5-1.7 2.8 1.7 5.3-3.1V9.2l1.3-1-.2-.2zm18.6-5.5l-1 .9-2.2-2-3.3 2.4V1.6h-.3l.1 16.2c-.3 0-1.2-.2-1.9-.4l-.2-13.5c0-1-.7-2.4-2.5-2.4s-3 1.4-3 2.8h.3c.1-.6.4-1.1 1-1.1s1.1.4 1.1 1.7v3.9c-1.8.1-2.9 1.1-2.9 2.4 0 .8.4 2 1.6 2V13c-.4-.2-.5-.5-.5-.7 0-.6.5-.8 1.3-.8h.4v6.2c-1.5.5-2.1 1.6-2.1 2.8 0 1.7 1.3 2.9 3.3 2.9 1.4 0 2.6-.2 3.8-.5 1-.2 2.3-.5 2.9-.5.8 0 1.1.4 1.1.9 0 .7-.3 1-.7 1.1v.2c1.6-.3 2.6-1.3 2.6-2.8s-1.5-2.4-3.1-2.4c-.8 0-2.5.3-3.7.5-1.4.3-2.8.5-3.2.5-.7 0-1.5-.3-1.5-1.3 0-.8.7-1.5 2.4-1.5.9 0 2 .1 3.1.4 1.2.3 2.3.6 3.3.6 1.5 0 2.8-.5 2.8-2.6V3.7l1.2-1-.2-.2zm-4.1 6.1c-.3.3-.7.6-1.2.6s-1-.3-1.2-.6V4.2l1-.7 1.4 1.3v3.8zm0 3c-.2-.2-.7-.5-1.2-.5s-1 .3-1.2.5V9c.2.2.7.5 1.2.5s1-.3 1.2-.5v2.6zm0 4.7c0 .8-.5 1.6-1.6 1.6h-.8V12c.2-.2.7-.5 1.2-.5s.9.3 1.2.5v4.3zm13.7-7.1l-3.2-2.3-4.9 2.8v6.5l-1 .8.1.2.8-.6 3.2 2.4 5-3V9.2zm-5.4 6.3V8.3l2.5 1.8v7.1l-2.5-1.7zm14.9-8.4h-.2c-.3.2-.6.4-.9.4-.4 0-.9-.2-1.1-.5h-.2l-1.7 1.9-1.7-1.9-3 2 .1.2.8-.5 1 1.1v6.3l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.4 2 3.1-2.1-.1-.2-.9.5-1.2-1V9c.5.5 1.1 1 1.8 1 1.4.1 2.2-1.3 2.3-2.9zm12 9.6L123 19l-4.6-7 3.3-5.1h.2c.4.4 1 .8 1.7.8s1.2-.4 1.5-.8h.2c-.1 2-1.5 3.2-2.5 3.2s-1.5-.5-2.1-.8l-.3.5 5 7.4 1-.6v.1zm-11-.5l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.2-.2-.8.5-1-1V.8h-.1l-3.6 2.4v.2c.4.2 1 .3 1 1.5v11.3zM143 2.9c0-2-1.9-2.5-3.4-2.5v.3c.9 0 1.6.3 1.6 1 0 .4-.3 1-1.2 1-.7 0-2.2-.4-3.3-.8-1.3-.4-2.5-.8-3.5-.8-2 0-3.4 1.5-3.4 3.2 0 1.5 1.1 2 1.5 2.2l.1-.2c-.3-.2-.6-.4-.6-1 0-.4.4-1.1 1.4-1.1.9 0 2.1.4 3.7.9 1.4.4 2.9.7 3.7.8V9l-1.5 1.3v.1l1.5 1.3V16c-.8.5-1.7.6-2.5.6-1.5 0-2.8-.4-3.9-1.6l4.1-2V6l-5 2.2c.5-1.3 1.6-2.2 2.6-2.9l-.1-.2c-3 .8-5.7 3.5-5.7 6.9 0 4 3.3 7 7 7 4 0 6.6-3.2 6.6-6.5h-.2c-.6 1.3-1.5 2.5-2.6 3.1v-4.1l1.6-1.3v-.1L140 8.8v-3c1.5 0 3-1 3-2.9zm-8.7 11l-1.2.6c-.7-.9-1.1-2.1-1.1-3.8 0-.7.1-1.5.3-2.1l2.1-.9-.1 6.2zm12.2-12h-.1l-2 1.7v.1l1.7 1.9h.2l2-1.7v-.1l-1.8-1.9zm3 14.8l-.8.5-1-1V9.3l1-.7-.2-.2-.7.6-1.8-2.1-2.9 2 .2.3.7-.5.9 1.1v6.5l-1.3 1 .1.2.7-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.1-.3zm16.7-.1l-.7.5-1.1-1V9.3l1-.8-.2-.2-.8.7-2.3-2.1-3 2.1-2.3-2.1L154 9l-1.8-2.1-2.9 2 .1.3.7-.5 1 1.1v6.5l-.8.8 2.3 1.9 2.2-2-.9-.9V9.3l.9-.6 1.5 1.4v6l-.8.8 2.3 1.9 2.2-2-.9-.9V9.3l.8-.5 1.6 1.4v6l-.7.7 2.3 2.1 3.1-2.1v-.3zm8.7-1.5l-2.5 1.9-2.5-2v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.8l3.5 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.3zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zm14.1-.9l-1.9-1.5c1.3-1.1 1.8-2.6 1.8-3.6v-.6h-.2c-.2.5-.6 1-1.4 1-.8 0-1.3-.4-1.8-1L176 9.3v3.6l1.7 1.3c-1.7 1.5-2 2.5-2 3.3 0 1 .5 1.7 1.3 2l.1-.2c-.2-.2-.4-.3-.4-.8 0-.3.4-.8 1.2-.8 1 0 1.6.7 1.9 1l4.3-2.6v-3.6h-.1zm-1.1-3c-.7 1.2-2.2 2.4-3.1 3l-1.1-.9V8.1c.4 1 1.5 1.8 2.6 1.8.7 0 1.1-.1 1.6-.4zm-1.7 8c-.5-1.1-1.7-1.9-2.9-1.9-.3 0-1.1 0-1.9.5.5-.8 1.8-2.2 3.5-3.2l1.2 1 .1 3.6z"></path></svg></a></div><div class="css-y3sf94 ez4a0qj1"><a href="https://myaccount.nytimes.com/auth/login?response_type=cookie&amp;client_id=vi" class="css-1kj7lfb"><button class="css-1bnxwmn ez4a0qj0" data-testid="login-button">Log In</button></a><div class="css-6n7j50"><button aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="User Settings" class="ez4a0qj4 css-1i8g3m4" data-testid="user-settings-button"><svg class="css-10m9xeu" viewBox="0 0 16 16" fill="#333"><path d="M8,10c-2.5,0-7,1.1-7,3.5V16h14v-2.5C15,11.1,10.5,10,8,10z"></path><circle cx="8" cy="4" r="4"></circle></svg></button></div></div></section><section id="masthead-bar-one" class="hasLinks css-15hmgas e1csuq9d3"><div class="css-uqyvli e1csuq9d0"></div><div class="css-1uqjmks e1csuq9d1"></div><div class="css-9e9ivx"><a href="https://myaccount.nytimes.com/auth/login?response_type=cookie&amp;client_id=vi" class="css-1gz70xg">Log In</a></div><div class="css-1bvtpon e1csuq9d2"><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/todayspaper" class="css-2bwtzy">Today’s Paper</a></div></section></header></div><div id="capsule-dropzone-belowMasthead" class="css-n4ogti"></div><div id="top-wrapper" class="css-rqw92o"><div id="top-slug" class="css-k2fwhk"><p>Advertisement</p></div><div class="ad top-wrapper" style="text-align:center;height:100%;display:block"><div id="top"></div></div></div></div><main id="site-content"><article id="interactive" class="interactive"><header id="interactive-header" class="dish interactive-header css-1p8vgzh e1n4ps4i1"><h1 itemProp="headline" class="interactive-heading css-1s4ffep e1h9rw200" id="interactive-heading">Joe Biden and Kamala Harris Got the Most Speaking Time During the Democratic Debate</h1><div class="css-1vegfwe interactive-byline-container"><p class="interactive-byline e1n4ps4i0 css-1c5207x e1jsehar1" id="interactive-byline" itemProp="author" itemscope="" itemType="http://schema.org/Person">By<!-- --> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/by/weiyi-cai" class="css-1riqqik e1jsehar0"><span class="css-1baulvz" itemProp="name">Weiyi Cai</span></a>, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/by/jasmine-c-lee" class="css-1riqqik e1jsehar0"><span class="css-1baulvz" itemProp="name">Jasmine C. Lee</span></a>, <span class="css-1baulvz" itemProp="name">Juliette Love</span> and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/by/alicia-parlapiano" class="css-1riqqik e1jsehar0"><span class="css-1baulvz last-byline" itemProp="name">Alicia Parlapiano</span></a><time id="interactive-timestamp" class="interactive-timestamp css-o15hd4 e16638kd0" dateTime="2019-07-31T20:11:48-04:00">July 31, 2019</time></p></div><div id="interactive-standalone-sharetools" class="css-dehhk5"><div class=""><div role="toolbar" aria-label="Social Media Share buttons, Save button, and Comments Panel with current comment count" class="interactive-sharetools css-brak7x" data-testid="share-tools"><ul class="css-y8aj3r"><li class="css-60hakz fb-share-item"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=9869919170&amp;link=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2Finteractive%2F2019%2F07%2F31%2Fus%2Felections%2Fdebate-speaking-time.html&amp;smid=fb-share&amp;name=Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate&amp;redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2F" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Share on Facebook"><svg class="css-4brsb6" viewBox="0 0 7 15" width="7" height="15"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M4.775 14.163V7.08h1.923l.255-2.441H4.775l.004-1.222c0-.636.06-.977.958-.977H6.94V0H5.016c-2.31 0-3.123 1.184-3.123 3.175V4.64H.453v2.44h1.44v7.083h2.882z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="css-60hakz twitter-share-item"><a href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fnyti.ms%2F2ypDmZH&amp;text=Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Share on Twitter"><svg viewBox="0 0 13 10" class="css-4brsb6" width="13" height="10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M5.987 2.772l.025.425-.429-.052c-1.562-.2-2.927-.876-4.086-2.011L.93.571.784.987c-.309.927-.111 1.906.533 2.565.343.364.266.416-.327.2-.206-.07-.386-.122-.403-.096-.06.06.146.85.309 1.161.223.434.678.858 1.176 1.11l.42.199-.497.009c-.481 0-.498.008-.447.19.172.564.85 1.162 1.606 1.422l.532.182-.464.277a4.833 4.833 0 0 1-2.3.641c-.387.009-.704.044-.704.07 0 .086 1.047.572 1.657.762 1.828.564 4 .32 5.631-.641 1.159-.685 2.318-2.045 2.859-3.363.292-.702.583-1.984.583-2.6 0-.398.026-.45.507-.927.283-.277.55-.58.6-.667.087-.165.078-.165-.36-.018-.73.26-.832.226-.472-.164.266-.278.584-.78.584-.928 0-.026-.129.018-.275.096a4.79 4.79 0 0 1-.755.294l-.464.148-.42-.286C9.66.467 9.335.293 9.163.24 8.725.12 8.055.137 7.66.276c-1.074.39-1.752 1.395-1.674 2.496z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="css-60hakz"><a href="mailto:?subject=NYTimes.com%3A%20Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate&amp;body=From%20The%20New%20York%20Times%3A%0A%0AJoe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate%0A%0AFollow%20along%20live%20during%20the%20debate.%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2Finteractive%2F2019%2F07%2F31%2Fus%2Felections%2Fdebate-speaking-time.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Email"><svg viewBox="0 0 15 9" class="css-4brsb6" width="15" height="9"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M.906 8.418V0L5.64 4.76.906 8.419zm13 0L9.174 4.761 13.906 0v8.418zM7.407 6.539l-1.13-1.137L.907 9h13l-5.37-3.598-1.13 1.137zM1.297 0h12.22l-6.11 5.095L1.297 0z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="css-60hakz"><div class="css-6n7j50"><button aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="More sharing options" class="css-16ogagc" data-testid=""><svg class="css-uhuo44" viewBox="0 0 16 13" width="16" height="13"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M15.406 5.359L8.978 0v3.215C3.82 3.215.406 8.107.406 12.66 1.653 9.133 4.29 7.517 8.978 7.517v3.2l6.428-5.358z" fill="#000"></path></svg></button></div></li></ul></div></div></div></header><section id="debate-speaking-time" data-id="100000006640050" class="interactive-standard interactive-content interactive-size-scoop css-15n42zn"><div class="css-17ih8de interactive-body"><!--
======================================================
THIS IS A GENERATED TEMPLATE FILE. DO NOT EDIT.
======================================================
-->
<!-- css generated from src/style.scss -->
<link id="nytg-rendered-css" href="https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/2019/07/31/dem-second-debate-2/69b183847b1e1b2d955336e62390f28f87241374/style.css" rel="stylesheet">
<!-- Check/Set Dark Mode -->
<!-- story top and cover -->
<!-- story links -->
<!-- LINKS -->
<!-- story body -->
<div class="g-story g-freebird g-max-limit " data-preview-slug="2019-03-10-vi-freebird">
<!-- data processed in process/process-data.js -->
<!-- data processed in process/freebird/process-graphic.js -->
<!-- asset wrapper : start -->
<!-- ASSET : START -->
<div class="g-asset g-graphic topchart " id="" style="max-width: 1000px">
<!-- Intro elements -->
<h3 class="g-caption_heading ">
<span class="g-hed-text">How Long Each Candidate Spoke</span>
</h3>
<div class="g-key keytype-inline">
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#436f82;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Health care</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#ae4544;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Immigration</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#8fbacc;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Civil rights and race</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#a4ad6f;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Climate change</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#d8cb98;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Economy</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#d86f45;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Women’s rights</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#7C5981;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Foreign policy</p>
</div>
<div class="g-key-row">
<span class="g-key-circle" style="background-color:#617bb5;"></span>
<p class="g-caption">Party strategy</p>
</div>
</div>
<!-- inner graphic element -->
<!-- print .html file -->
<div id='timechart' class='g-show-issues '>
<!--
<p class="g-caption_heading">How Long Each Candidate Spoke </p>
-->
<div class='chart'>
</div>
</div>
<!-- or print custom, pre-generated div with ID and classes -->
<!-- or print missing file warning -->
<!-- asset wrapper : end -->
<!-- ASSET : END -->
<div class="g-source ">
<span class="g-credit">Each bar segment represents the length of a candidate’s response to a question.</span>
</div>
</div>
<p class="g-body " id="">
Former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. and Senator Kamala Harris of California spoke the most during Wednesday night’s Democratic presidential debate. Senators Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/30/us/elections/debate-speaking-time.html">got the most speaking time</a> during Tuesday night’s debate.
</p>
<!-- data processed in process/freebird/process-graphic.js -->
<!-- asset wrapper : start -->
<!-- ASSET : START -->
<div class="g-asset g-graphic " id="" style="max-width: 1000px">
<!-- Intro elements -->
<!-- inner graphic element -->
<!-- print .html file -->
<div id='palette'>
</div>
<!-- or print custom, pre-generated div with ID and classes -->
<!-- or print missing file warning -->
<!-- asset wrapper : end -->
<!-- ASSET : END -->
</div>
<p class="g-body " id="">
<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/31/us/politics/live-updates-democratic-debate.html?">Get complete coverage of tonight’s debate »</a>
</p>
</div>
<!-- methodology -->
<!-- related content -->
<!-- Opinion detection -->
<script>
var NYTG_DEMDEBATES = [{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"yang","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"inslee","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"harris","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"gabbard","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"deblasio","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"castro","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"booker","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"biden","topic":""},{"elapsed":"0.00","timestamp":"","speaker":"bennet","topic":""},{"elapsed":"591.53","timestamp":"8:03:37 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"77.24","timestamp":"8:13:29 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"89.84","timestamp":"8:14:46 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"82.30","timestamp":"8:16:16 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"76.71","timestamp":"8:17:38 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"68.49","timestamp":"8:18:55 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"72.29","timestamp":"8:20:03 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"75.91","timestamp":"8:21:16 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"34.44","timestamp":"8:22:32 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"15.50","timestamp":"8:23:06 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"70.86","timestamp":"8:23:21 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"72.75","timestamp":"8:24:32 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"63.98","timestamp":"8:25:45 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"opening"},{"elapsed":"29.66","timestamp":"8:26:49 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"80.63","timestamp":"8:27:19 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.07","timestamp":"8:28:39 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"30.59","timestamp":"8:28:42 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"45.81","timestamp":"8:29:13 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"2.56","timestamp":"8:29:59 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"25.84","timestamp":"8:30:01 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"39.82","timestamp":"8:30:27 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"39.05","timestamp":"8:31:07 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"14.68","timestamp":"8:31:46 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"40.22","timestamp":"8:32:01 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"14.69","timestamp":"8:32:41 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"70.43","timestamp":"8:32:56 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"4.95","timestamp":"8:34:06 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"38.62","timestamp":"8:34:11 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"41.21","timestamp":"8:34:50 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"17.66","timestamp":"8:35:31 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"77.80","timestamp":"8:35:49 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.31","timestamp":"8:37:06 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"54.02","timestamp":"8:37:10 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"43.90","timestamp":"8:38:04 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.06","timestamp":"8:38:48 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.29","timestamp":"8:38:51 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"10.61","timestamp":"8:39:28 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"66.75","timestamp":"8:39:39 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"6.83","timestamp":"8:40:45 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"36.16","timestamp":"8:40:52 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"5.00","timestamp":"8:41:28 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"35.86","timestamp":"8:41:33 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"7.65","timestamp":"8:42:09 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"33.97","timestamp":"8:42:17 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"9.05","timestamp":"8:42:51 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"40.03","timestamp":"8:43:00 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"21.55","timestamp":"8:43:40 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"68.99","timestamp":"8:44:01 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"6.46","timestamp":"8:45:10 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"36.19","timestamp":"8:45:17 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.14","timestamp":"8:45:53 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.96","timestamp":"8:45:56 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"5.60","timestamp":"8:46:34 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"17.19","timestamp":"8:46:40 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"4.58","timestamp":"8:46:57 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"35.16","timestamp":"8:47:02 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"5.36","timestamp":"8:47:37 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"30.43","timestamp":"8:47:42 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"4.12","timestamp":"8:48:12 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"58.34","timestamp":"8:48:17 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.33","timestamp":"8:49:15 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"43.24","timestamp":"8:49:18 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"3.25","timestamp":"8:50:01 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"38.07","timestamp":"8:50:05 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"health-care"},{"elapsed":"20.04","timestamp":"8:50:43 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"69.48","timestamp":"8:51:03 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"3.95","timestamp":"8:52:12 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"45.47","timestamp":"8:52:16 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"11.32","timestamp":"8:53:02 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"46.46","timestamp":"8:53:13 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"12.47","timestamp":"8:54:00 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"33.27","timestamp":"8:54:12 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"2.91","timestamp":"8:54:45 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"50.71","timestamp":"8:54:48 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"14.12","timestamp":"8:55:39 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"28.32","timestamp":"8:55:53 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"11.15","timestamp":"8:56:21 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"58.88","timestamp":"8:56:32 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"3.58","timestamp":"8:57:31 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"42.34","timestamp":"8:57:35 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"6.39","timestamp":"8:58:17 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"28.27","timestamp":"8:58:24 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"3.65","timestamp":"8:58:52 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.29","timestamp":"8:58:56 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"2.11","timestamp":"8:59:33 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"28.13","timestamp":"8:59:35 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"13.94","timestamp":"9:00:03 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"75.39","timestamp":"9:00:17 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"3.98","timestamp":"9:01:32 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"40.01","timestamp":"9:01:36 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"4.08","timestamp":"9:02:16 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"39.17","timestamp":"9:02:20 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"5.04","timestamp":"9:03:00 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"35.39","timestamp":"9:03:05 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"34.91","timestamp":"9:03:40 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"16.26","timestamp":"9:04:15 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"45.98","timestamp":"9:04:31 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"3.39","timestamp":"9:05:17 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"27.06","timestamp":"9:05:21 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"25.03","timestamp":"9:05:48 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":""},{"elapsed":"39.35","timestamp":"9:06:13 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"2.14","timestamp":"9:06:52 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"26.60","timestamp":"9:06:54 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"2.03","timestamp":"9:07:21 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.67","timestamp":"9:07:23 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"immigration"},{"elapsed":"258.75","timestamp":"9:08:00 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"55.78","timestamp":"9:12:19 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.61","timestamp":"9:13:15 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"47.85","timestamp":"9:13:18 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"9.64","timestamp":"9:14:05 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"48.64","timestamp":"9:14:15 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.07","timestamp":"9:15:04 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"48.98","timestamp":"9:15:06 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.75","timestamp":"9:15:55 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"31.33","timestamp":"9:15:58 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"42.08","timestamp":"9:16:29 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"5.96","timestamp":"9:17:11 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"49.53","timestamp":"9:17:17 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"4.45","timestamp":"9:18:06 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"51.06","timestamp":"9:18:11 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.78","timestamp":"9:19:02 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"28.93","timestamp":"9:19:05 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"6.52","timestamp":"9:19:34 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"54.90","timestamp":"9:19:40 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.63","timestamp":"9:20:35 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"49.82","timestamp":"9:20:39 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.66","timestamp":"9:21:29 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"33.83","timestamp":"9:21:32 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"12.67","timestamp":"9:22:06 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"5.76","timestamp":"9:22:19 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.08","timestamp":"9:22:24 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"29.82","timestamp":"9:22:28 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"27.85","timestamp":"9:22:57 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"90.73","timestamp":"9:23:25 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"10.05","timestamp":"9:24:56 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"56.69","timestamp":"9:25:06 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.21","timestamp":"9:26:03 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"36.14","timestamp":"9:26:06 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"15.11","timestamp":"9:26:42 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"50.09","timestamp":"9:26:57 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"5.88","timestamp":"9:27:47 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.43","timestamp":"9:27:53 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"9.45","timestamp":"9:28:31 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"25.06","timestamp":"9:28:40 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.86","timestamp":"9:29:05 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"40.34","timestamp":"9:29:09 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"10.85","timestamp":"9:29:49 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"84.33","timestamp":"9:30:00 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"9.76","timestamp":"9:31:24 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"90.86","timestamp":"9:31:34 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"7.27","timestamp":"9:33:05 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"63.33","timestamp":"9:33:12 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"18.91","timestamp":"9:34:16 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"67.13","timestamp":"9:34:35 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.69","timestamp":"9:35:42 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"67.44","timestamp":"9:35:45 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"civil-rights"},{"elapsed":"28.35","timestamp":"9:36:53 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"76.63","timestamp":"9:37:21 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"11.45","timestamp":"9:38:38 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"38.97","timestamp":"9:38:49 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"8.80","timestamp":"9:39:28 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"34.93","timestamp":"9:39:37 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"37.11","timestamp":"9:40:12 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"31.64","timestamp":"9:40:49 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"9.31","timestamp":"9:41:21 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"10.17","timestamp":"9:41:30 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"14.64","timestamp":"9:41:40 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"2.77","timestamp":"9:41:55 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"33.70","timestamp":"9:41:58 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"18.18","timestamp":"9:42:31 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"78.54","timestamp":"9:42:49 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"5.17","timestamp":"9:44:08 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"44.79","timestamp":"9:44:13 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"6.66","timestamp":"9:44:58 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"72.70","timestamp":"9:45:05 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"climate"},{"elapsed":"26.28","timestamp":"9:46:17 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"69.70","timestamp":"9:46:44 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"lead"},{"elapsed":"5.43","timestamp":"9:47:53 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"34.29","timestamp":"9:47:59 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"lead"},{"elapsed":"43.59","timestamp":"9:48:33 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"60.54","timestamp":"9:49:17 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"5.35","timestamp":"9:50:17 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"45.71","timestamp":"9:50:22 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"21.53","timestamp":"9:51:08 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"63.97","timestamp":"9:51:30 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"9.81","timestamp":"9:52:34 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"42.53","timestamp":"9:52:44 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"3.98","timestamp":"9:53:26 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"51.81","timestamp":"9:53:30 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"2.21","timestamp":"9:54:22 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"51.78","timestamp":"9:54:24 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"246.77","timestamp":"9:55:16 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"71.67","timestamp":"9:59:23 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"22.97","timestamp":"10:00:34 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"52.93","timestamp":"10:00:57 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"4.90","timestamp":"10:01:50 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"20.35","timestamp":"10:01:55 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"9.39","timestamp":"10:02:15 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"35.44","timestamp":"10:02:25 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"6.07","timestamp":"10:03:00 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"26.18","timestamp":"10:03:06 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"5.46","timestamp":"10:03:32 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.67","timestamp":"10:03:38 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"6.90","timestamp":"10:04:16 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"16.06","timestamp":"10:04:23 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"4.01","timestamp":"10:04:39 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"3.34","timestamp":"10:04:43 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"25.03","timestamp":"10:04:46 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"77.74","timestamp":"10:05:11 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"24.20","timestamp":"10:06:29 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"61.15","timestamp":"10:06:53 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"economy"},{"elapsed":"2.63","timestamp":"10:07:54 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"42.09","timestamp":"10:07:57 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"7.98","timestamp":"10:08:39 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"63.11","timestamp":"10:08:47 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"46.24","timestamp":"10:09:50 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"34.82","timestamp":"10:10:36 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.43","timestamp":"10:11:11 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"34.41","timestamp":"10:11:13 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"25.19","timestamp":"10:11:48 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"7.81","timestamp":"10:12:13 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"47.09","timestamp":"10:12:21 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"4.20","timestamp":"10:13:08 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"43.16","timestamp":"10:13:12 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"9.58","timestamp":"10:13:55 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"3.25","timestamp":"10:14:05 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"3.30","timestamp":"10:14:08 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"2.19","timestamp":"10:14:11 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"37.64","timestamp":"10:14:14 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"womens-rights"},{"elapsed":"15.07","timestamp":"10:14:51 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"40.79","timestamp":"10:15:06 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"2.83","timestamp":"10:15:47 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"62.82","timestamp":"10:15:50 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"23.91","timestamp":"10:16:53 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"59.17","timestamp":"10:17:17 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"2.93","timestamp":"10:18:16 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"46.45","timestamp":"10:18:19 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"9.97","timestamp":"10:19:05 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"42.53","timestamp":"10:19:15 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"10.01","timestamp":"10:19:58 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"45.49","timestamp":"10:20:08 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"5.69","timestamp":"10:20:53 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"3.22","timestamp":"10:20:59 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"foreign-policy"},{"elapsed":"39.49","timestamp":"10:21:02 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"41.06","timestamp":"10:21:42 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"2.83","timestamp":"10:22:23 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"60.01","timestamp":"10:22:25 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"2.31","timestamp":"10:23:25 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"34.37","timestamp":"10:23:28 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"3.31","timestamp":"10:24:02 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"51.25","timestamp":"10:24:05 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"2.57","timestamp":"10:24:57 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"54.75","timestamp":"10:24:59 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"0.78","timestamp":"10:25:54 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"55.71","timestamp":"10:25:55 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"8.97","timestamp":"10:26:50 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"20.77","timestamp":"10:26:59 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"party-strategy"},{"elapsed":"249.84","timestamp":"10:27:20 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""},{"elapsed":"71.99","timestamp":"10:31:30 PM","speaker":"deblasio","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"89.00","timestamp":"10:32:42 PM","speaker":"bennet","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"103.59","timestamp":"10:34:11 PM","speaker":"inslee","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"98.89","timestamp":"10:35:55 PM","speaker":"gillibrand","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"97.09","timestamp":"10:37:34 PM","speaker":"gabbard","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"74.99","timestamp":"10:39:11 PM","speaker":"castro","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"76.32","timestamp":"10:40:26 PM","speaker":"yang","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"123.06","timestamp":"10:41:42 PM","speaker":"booker","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"127.49","timestamp":"10:43:45 PM","speaker":"harris","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"75.28","timestamp":"10:45:52 PM","speaker":"biden","topic":"closing"},{"elapsed":"","timestamp":"10:47:08 PM","speaker":"moderator","topic":""}]
</script>
<!-- js generated from _assets/build.js -->
<script id="nytg-rendered-js" src="https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/2019/07/31/dem-second-debate-2/69b183847b1e1b2d955336e62390f28f87241374/build.js"></script>
<!-- Pipeline: 2019-07-31-dem-second-debate-2 | July 31, 2019, 11:12PM | 69b183847b1e1b2d955336e62390f28f87241374 -->
</div></section><div class="css-i29ckm"><div role="toolbar" aria-label="Social Media Share buttons, Save button, and Comments Panel with current comment count" class="interactive-sharetools css-brak7x" data-testid="share-tools"><ul class="css-y8aj3r"><li class="fb-share-item css-ar1l6a"><a href="https://www.facebook.com/dialog/feed?app_id=9869919170&amp;link=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2Finteractive%2F2019%2F07%2F31%2Fus%2Felections%2Fdebate-speaking-time.html&amp;smid=fb-share&amp;name=Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate&amp;redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2F" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Share on Facebook"><svg class="css-4brsb6" viewBox="0 0 7 15" width="7" height="15"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M4.775 14.163V7.08h1.923l.255-2.441H4.775l.004-1.222c0-.636.06-.977.958-.977H6.94V0H5.016c-2.31 0-3.123 1.184-3.123 3.175V4.64H.453v2.44h1.44v7.083h2.882z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="twitter-share-item css-ar1l6a"><a href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fnyti.ms%2F2ypDmZH&amp;text=Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Share on Twitter"><svg viewBox="0 0 13 10" class="css-4brsb6" width="13" height="10"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M5.987 2.772l.025.425-.429-.052c-1.562-.2-2.927-.876-4.086-2.011L.93.571.784.987c-.309.927-.111 1.906.533 2.565.343.364.266.416-.327.2-.206-.07-.386-.122-.403-.096-.06.06.146.85.309 1.161.223.434.678.858 1.176 1.11l.42.199-.497.009c-.481 0-.498.008-.447.19.172.564.85 1.162 1.606 1.422l.532.182-.464.277a4.833 4.833 0 0 1-2.3.641c-.387.009-.704.044-.704.07 0 .086 1.047.572 1.657.762 1.828.564 4 .32 5.631-.641 1.159-.685 2.318-2.045 2.859-3.363.292-.702.583-1.984.583-2.6 0-.398.026-.45.507-.927.283-.277.55-.58.6-.667.087-.165.078-.165-.36-.018-.73.26-.832.226-.472-.164.266-.278.584-.78.584-.928 0-.026-.129.018-.275.096a4.79 4.79 0 0 1-.755.294l-.464.148-.42-.286C9.66.467 9.335.293 9.163.24 8.725.12 8.055.137 7.66.276c-1.074.39-1.752 1.395-1.674 2.496z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="css-ar1l6a"><a href="mailto:?subject=NYTimes.com%3A%20Joe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate&amp;body=From%20The%20New%20York%20Times%3A%0A%0AJoe%20Biden%20and%20Kamala%20Harris%20Got%20the%20Most%20Speaking%20Time%20During%20the%20Democratic%20Debate%0A%0AFollow%20along%20live%20during%20the%20debate.%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2Finteractive%2F2019%2F07%2F31%2Fus%2Felections%2Fdebate-speaking-time.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Email"><svg viewBox="0 0 15 9" class="css-4brsb6" width="15" height="9"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M.906 8.418V0L5.64 4.76.906 8.419zm13 0L9.174 4.761 13.906 0v8.418zM7.407 6.539l-1.13-1.137L.907 9h13l-5.37-3.598-1.13 1.137zM1.297 0h12.22l-6.11 5.095L1.297 0z" fill="#000"></path></svg></a></li><li class="css-ar1l6a"><div class="css-6n7j50"><button aria-haspopup="true" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="More sharing options" class="css-16ogagc" data-testid=""><svg class="css-uhuo44" viewBox="0 0 16 13" width="16" height="13"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M15.406 5.359L8.978 0v3.215C3.82 3.215.406 8.107.406 12.66 1.653 9.133 4.29 7.517 8.978 7.517v3.2l6.428-5.358z" fill="#000"></path></svg></button></div></li></ul></div></div></article></main><div id="standalone-footer"><div><div class=""><div id="interactive-footer-wrapper"><div><div id="capsule-dropzone-aboveFooter" class="css-8atqhb"></div><div class="css-cfo9c3"></div></div><div id="bottom-wrapper" class="css-1157aqr"><div id="bottom-slug" class="css-k2fwhk"><p>Advertisement</p></div><div class="ad bottom-wrapper" style="text-align:center;height:100%;display:block"><div id="bottom"></div></div></div><nav class="css-1ropbjl" id="site-index" aria-labelledby="site-index-label" data-testid="site-index"><div class="css-uw59u"><header class="css-jxzr5i" data-testid="site-index-header"><h2 class="css-vz7hjd" id="site-index-label">Site Index</h2><a href="/"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="css-oylsik" viewBox="0 0 184 25" fill="#000"><path d="M13.8 2.9c0-2-1.9-2.5-3.4-2.5v.3c.9 0 1.6.3 1.6 1 0 .4-.3 1-1.2 1-.7 0-2.2-.4-3.3-.8C6.2 1.4 5 1 4 1 2 1 .6 2.5.6 4.2c0 1.5 1.1 2 1.5 2.2l.1-.2c-.2-.2-.5-.4-.5-1 0-.4.4-1.1 1.4-1.1.9 0 2.1.4 3.7.9 1.4.4 2.9.7 3.7.8v3.1L9 10.2v.1l1.5 1.3v4.3c-.8.5-1.7.6-2.5.6-1.5 0-2.8-.4-3.9-1.6l4.1-2V6l-5 2.2C3.6 6.9 4.7 6 5.8 5.4l-.1-.3c-3 .8-5.7 3.6-5.7 7 0 4 3.3 7 7 7 4 0 6.6-3.2 6.6-6.5h-.2c-.6 1.3-1.5 2.5-2.6 3.1v-4.1l1.6-1.3v-.1l-1.6-1.3V5.8c1.5 0 3-1 3-2.9zm-8.7 11l-1.2.6c-.7-.9-1.1-2.1-1.1-3.8 0-.7 0-1.5.2-2.1l2.1-.9v6.2zm10.6 2.3l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.1-.2-.8.5-1-1V9.4l.8-.6 1.7 1.4v6.1c0 3.8-.8 4.4-2.5 5v.3c2.8.1 5.4-.8 5.4-5.7V9.3l.9-.7-.2-.2-.8.6-2.5-2.1L18.5 9V.8h-.2l-3.5 2.4v.2c.4.2 1 .4 1 1.5l-.1 11.3zM34 15.1L31.5 17 29 15v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.6l-1 .8.2.2.9-.7 3.4 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.4zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zM53.1 2c0-.3-.1-.6-.2-.9h-.2c-.3.8-.7 1.2-1.7 1.2-.9 0-1.5-.5-1.9-.9l-2.9 3.3.2.2 1-.9c.6.5 1.1.9 2.5 1v8.3L44 3.2c-.5-.8-1.2-1.9-2.6-1.9-1.6 0-3 1.4-2.8 3.6h.3c.1-.6.4-1.3 1.1-1.3.5 0 1 .5 1.3 1v3.3c-1.8 0-3 .8-3 2.3 0 .8.4 2 1.6 2.3v-.2c-.2-.2-.3-.4-.3-.7 0-.5.4-.9 1.1-.9h.5v4.2c-2.1 0-3.8 1.2-3.8 3.2 0 1.9 1.6 2.8 3.4 2.7v-.2c-1.1-.1-1.6-.6-1.6-1.3 0-.9.6-1.3 1.4-1.3.8 0 1.5.5 2 1.1l2.9-3.2-.2-.2-.7.8c-1.1-1-1.7-1.3-3-1.5V5l8 14h.6V5c1.5-.1 2.9-1.3 2.9-3zm7.3 13.1L57.9 17l-2.5-2v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.6l-1 .8.2.2.9-.7 3.4 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.4zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zM76.7 8l-.7.5-1.9-1.6-2.2 2 .9.9v7.5l-2.4-1.5V9.6l.8-.5-2.3-2.2-2.2 2 .9.9V17l-.3.2-2.1-1.5v-6c0-1.4-.7-1.8-1.5-2.3-.7-.5-1.1-.8-1.1-1.5 0-.6.6-.9.9-1.1v-.2c-.8 0-2.9.8-2.9 2.7 0 1 .5 1.4 1 1.9s1 .9 1 1.8v5.8l-1.1.8.2.2 1-.8 2.3 2 2.5-1.7 2.8 1.7 5.3-3.1V9.2l1.3-1-.2-.2zm18.6-5.5l-1 .9-2.2-2-3.3 2.4V1.6h-.3l.1 16.2c-.3 0-1.2-.2-1.9-.4l-.2-13.5c0-1-.7-2.4-2.5-2.4s-3 1.4-3 2.8h.3c.1-.6.4-1.1 1-1.1s1.1.4 1.1 1.7v3.9c-1.8.1-2.9 1.1-2.9 2.4 0 .8.4 2 1.6 2V13c-.4-.2-.5-.5-.5-.7 0-.6.5-.8 1.3-.8h.4v6.2c-1.5.5-2.1 1.6-2.1 2.8 0 1.7 1.3 2.9 3.3 2.9 1.4 0 2.6-.2 3.8-.5 1-.2 2.3-.5 2.9-.5.8 0 1.1.4 1.1.9 0 .7-.3 1-.7 1.1v.2c1.6-.3 2.6-1.3 2.6-2.8s-1.5-2.4-3.1-2.4c-.8 0-2.5.3-3.7.5-1.4.3-2.8.5-3.2.5-.7 0-1.5-.3-1.5-1.3 0-.8.7-1.5 2.4-1.5.9 0 2 .1 3.1.4 1.2.3 2.3.6 3.3.6 1.5 0 2.8-.5 2.8-2.6V3.7l1.2-1-.2-.2zm-4.1 6.1c-.3.3-.7.6-1.2.6s-1-.3-1.2-.6V4.2l1-.7 1.4 1.3v3.8zm0 3c-.2-.2-.7-.5-1.2-.5s-1 .3-1.2.5V9c.2.2.7.5 1.2.5s1-.3 1.2-.5v2.6zm0 4.7c0 .8-.5 1.6-1.6 1.6h-.8V12c.2-.2.7-.5 1.2-.5s.9.3 1.2.5v4.3zm13.7-7.1l-3.2-2.3-4.9 2.8v6.5l-1 .8.1.2.8-.6 3.2 2.4 5-3V9.2zm-5.4 6.3V8.3l2.5 1.8v7.1l-2.5-1.7zm14.9-8.4h-.2c-.3.2-.6.4-.9.4-.4 0-.9-.2-1.1-.5h-.2l-1.7 1.9-1.7-1.9-3 2 .1.2.8-.5 1 1.1v6.3l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.4 2 3.1-2.1-.1-.2-.9.5-1.2-1V9c.5.5 1.1 1 1.8 1 1.4.1 2.2-1.3 2.3-2.9zm12 9.6L123 19l-4.6-7 3.3-5.1h.2c.4.4 1 .8 1.7.8s1.2-.4 1.5-.8h.2c-.1 2-1.5 3.2-2.5 3.2s-1.5-.5-2.1-.8l-.3.5 5 7.4 1-.6v.1zm-11-.5l-1.3 1 .2.2.6-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.2-.2-.8.5-1-1V.8h-.1l-3.6 2.4v.2c.4.2 1 .3 1 1.5v11.3zM143 2.9c0-2-1.9-2.5-3.4-2.5v.3c.9 0 1.6.3 1.6 1 0 .4-.3 1-1.2 1-.7 0-2.2-.4-3.3-.8-1.3-.4-2.5-.8-3.5-.8-2 0-3.4 1.5-3.4 3.2 0 1.5 1.1 2 1.5 2.2l.1-.2c-.3-.2-.6-.4-.6-1 0-.4.4-1.1 1.4-1.1.9 0 2.1.4 3.7.9 1.4.4 2.9.7 3.7.8V9l-1.5 1.3v.1l1.5 1.3V16c-.8.5-1.7.6-2.5.6-1.5 0-2.8-.4-3.9-1.6l4.1-2V6l-5 2.2c.5-1.3 1.6-2.2 2.6-2.9l-.1-.2c-3 .8-5.7 3.5-5.7 6.9 0 4 3.3 7 7 7 4 0 6.6-3.2 6.6-6.5h-.2c-.6 1.3-1.5 2.5-2.6 3.1v-4.1l1.6-1.3v-.1L140 8.8v-3c1.5 0 3-1 3-2.9zm-8.7 11l-1.2.6c-.7-.9-1.1-2.1-1.1-3.8 0-.7.1-1.5.3-2.1l2.1-.9-.1 6.2zm12.2-12h-.1l-2 1.7v.1l1.7 1.9h.2l2-1.7v-.1l-1.8-1.9zm3 14.8l-.8.5-1-1V9.3l1-.7-.2-.2-.7.6-1.8-2.1-2.9 2 .2.3.7-.5.9 1.1v6.5l-1.3 1 .1.2.7-.5 2.2 2 3-2-.1-.3zm16.7-.1l-.7.5-1.1-1V9.3l1-.8-.2-.2-.8.7-2.3-2.1-3 2.1-2.3-2.1L154 9l-1.8-2.1-2.9 2 .1.3.7-.5 1 1.1v6.5l-.8.8 2.3 1.9 2.2-2-.9-.9V9.3l.9-.6 1.5 1.4v6l-.8.8 2.3 1.9 2.2-2-.9-.9V9.3l.8-.5 1.6 1.4v6l-.7.7 2.3 2.1 3.1-2.1v-.3zm8.7-1.5l-2.5 1.9-2.5-2v-1.2l4.7-3.2v-.1l-2.4-3.6-5.2 2.8v6.8l3.5 2.5 4.5-3.6-.1-.3zm-5-1.7V8.5l.2-.1 2.2 3.5-2.4 1.5zm14.1-.9l-1.9-1.5c1.3-1.1 1.8-2.6 1.8-3.6v-.6h-.2c-.2.5-.6 1-1.4 1-.8 0-1.3-.4-1.8-1L176 9.3v3.6l1.7 1.3c-1.7 1.5-2 2.5-2 3.3 0 1 .5 1.7 1.3 2l.1-.2c-.2-.2-.4-.3-.4-.8 0-.3.4-.8 1.2-.8 1 0 1.6.7 1.9 1l4.3-2.6v-3.6h-.1zm-1.1-3c-.7 1.2-2.2 2.4-3.1 3l-1.1-.9V8.1c.4 1 1.5 1.8 2.6 1.8.7 0 1.1-.1 1.6-.4zm-1.7 8c-.5-1.1-1.7-1.9-2.9-1.9-.3 0-1.1 0-1.9.5.5-.8 1.8-2.2 3.5-3.2l1.2 1 .1 3.6z"></path></svg></a><div class="css-1otr2jl" data-testid="go-to-homepage"><a class="css-1c8n994" href="/">Go to Home Page »</a></div></header><div class="css-qtw155" data-testid="site-index-accordion"><div class=" " role="tablist" aria-multiselectable="true" data-testid="accordion"><div class="" data-testid="accordion-item"><header aria-controls="body-siteindex-0" id="item-siteindex-0" class="css-mn5hq9" role="tab" tabindex="0" aria-expanded="false" data-testid="accordion-item-header">news</header><div class="css-1hyfx7x" id="body-siteindex-0" aria-labelledby="item-siteindex-0" aria-expanded="false" role="tabpanel" data-testid="accordion-item-body"><ul class="css-1gprdgz" data-testid="site-index-accordion-list"><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">home page</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/world" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">world</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/us" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">U.S.</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/politics" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">politics</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/2020-election" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Election 2020</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/nyregion" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">New York</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/business" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">business</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/technology" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">tech</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/science" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">science</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/climate" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">climate</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/sports" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">sports</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/obituaries" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">obituaries</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/upshot" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">the upshot</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/es/" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Español</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://cn.nytimes.com/" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">中文网</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/todayspaper" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">today&#x27;s paper</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/corrections" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">corrections</a></li></ul></div></div><div class="" data-testid="accordion-item"><header aria-controls="body-siteindex-1" id="item-siteindex-1" class="css-mn5hq9" role="tab" tabindex="0" aria-expanded="false" data-testid="accordion-item-header">opinion</header><div class="css-1hyfx7x" id="body-siteindex-1" aria-labelledby="item-siteindex-1" aria-expanded="false" role="tabpanel" data-testid="accordion-item-body"><ul class="css-1gprdgz" data-testid="site-index-accordion-list"><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">today&#x27;s opinion</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/columnists" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">op-ed columnists</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/editorials" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">editorials</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/contributors" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">op-ed Contributors</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/letters" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">letters</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/sunday" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">sunday review</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/opinion" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">video: opinion</a></li></ul></div></div><div class="" data-testid="accordion-item"><header aria-controls="body-siteindex-2" id="item-siteindex-2" class="css-mn5hq9" role="tab" tabindex="0" aria-expanded="false" data-testid="accordion-item-header">arts</header><div class="css-1hyfx7x" id="body-siteindex-2" aria-labelledby="item-siteindex-2" aria-expanded="false" role="tabpanel" data-testid="accordion-item-body"><ul class="css-1gprdgz" data-testid="site-index-accordion-list"><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">today&#x27;s arts</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/design" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">art &amp; design</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/books" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">books</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/dance" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">dance</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/movies" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">movies</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/music" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">music</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/spotlight/pop-culture" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Pop Culture</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/television" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">television</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/theater" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">theater</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/watching" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">watching</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/arts" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">video: arts</a></li></ul></div></div><div class="" data-testid="accordion-item"><header aria-controls="body-siteindex-3" id="item-siteindex-3" class="css-mn5hq9" role="tab" tabindex="0" aria-expanded="false" data-testid="accordion-item-header">living</header><div class="css-1hyfx7x" id="body-siteindex-3" aria-labelledby="item-siteindex-3" aria-expanded="false" role="tabpanel" data-testid="accordion-item-body"><ul class="css-1gprdgz" data-testid="site-index-accordion-list"><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/automobiles" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">automobiles</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia smartphone"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://cooking.nytimes.com/" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Cooking</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/crosswords" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">crossword</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/education" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">education</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/food" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">food</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/health" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">health</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/jobs" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">jobs</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/magazine" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">magazine</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://parenting.nytimes.com/" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">parenting</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/realestate" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">real estate</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/style" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">style</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/t-magazine" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">t magazine</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/travel" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">travel</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/fashion/weddings" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">love</a></li></ul></div></div><div class="" data-testid="accordion-item"><header aria-controls="body-siteindex-4" id="item-siteindex-4" class="css-mn5hq9" role="tab" tabindex="0" aria-expanded="false" data-testid="accordion-item-header">listings &amp; more</header><div class="css-1hyfx7x" id="body-siteindex-4" aria-labelledby="item-siteindex-4" aria-expanded="false" role="tabpanel" data-testid="accordion-item-body"><ul class="css-1gprdgz" data-testid="site-index-accordion-list"><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/reader-center" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Reader Center</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://thewirecutter.com" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Wirecutter</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="http://nytconferences.com/" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Live Events</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/learning" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">The Learning Network</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="http://www.nytimes.com/marketing/tools-and-services" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">tools &amp; services</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/events" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">N.Y.C. events guide</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/multimedia" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">multimedia</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/lens" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">photography</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">video</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/newsletters" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">Newsletters</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/store" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">NYT store</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://www.nytimes.com/times-journeys" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">times journeys</a></li><li class="css-10t7hia"><a class="css-mzqdl" href="https://myaccount.nytimes.com/membercenter/myaccount.html" data-testid="accordion-item-list-link">manage my account</a></li></ul></div></div></div></div><div class="css-v0l3hm" data-testid="site-index-sections"><div class="css-g4gku8" data-testid="site-index-section"><section class="css-1rr4qq7" aria-labelledby="site-index-section-label-0"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-section-label-0">news</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-section-list"><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">home page</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/world" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">world</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/us" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">U.S.</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/politics" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">politics</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/2020-election" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Election 2020</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/nyregion" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">New York</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/business" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">business</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/technology" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">tech</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/science" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">science</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/climate" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">climate</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/sports" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">sports</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/obituaries" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">obituaries</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/upshot" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">the upshot</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/es/" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Español</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://cn.nytimes.com/" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">中文网</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/todayspaper" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">today&#x27;s paper</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/corrections" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">corrections</a></li></ul></section><section class="css-1rr4qq7" aria-labelledby="site-index-section-label-1"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-section-label-1">opinion</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-section-list"><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">today&#x27;s opinion</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/columnists" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">op-ed columnists</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/editorials" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">editorials</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/contributors" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">op-ed Contributors</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/letters" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">letters</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/opinion/sunday" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">sunday review</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/opinion" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">video: opinion</a></li></ul></section><section class="css-1rr4qq7" aria-labelledby="site-index-section-label-2"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-section-label-2">arts</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-section-list"><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">today&#x27;s arts</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/design" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">art &amp; design</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/books" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">books</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/dance" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">dance</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/movies" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">movies</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/music" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">music</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/spotlight/pop-culture" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Pop Culture</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/arts/television" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">television</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/theater" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">theater</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/watching" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">watching</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/arts" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">video: arts</a></li></ul></section><section class="css-1rr4qq7" aria-labelledby="site-index-section-label-3"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-section-label-3">living</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-section-list"><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/automobiles" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">automobiles</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3 smartphone"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://cooking.nytimes.com/" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Cooking</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/crosswords" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">crossword</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/education" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">education</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/food" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">food</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/health" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">health</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/jobs" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">jobs</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/magazine" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">magazine</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://parenting.nytimes.com/" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">parenting</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/realestate" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">real estate</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/style" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">style</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/t-magazine" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">t magazine</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/travel" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">travel</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/fashion/weddings" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">love</a></li></ul></section><section class="css-1rr4qq7" aria-labelledby="site-index-section-label-4"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-section-label-4">more</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-section-list"><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/reader-center" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Reader Center</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://thewirecutter.com" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Wirecutter</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="http://nytconferences.com/" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Live Events</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/learning" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">The Learning Network</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="http://www.nytimes.com/marketing/tools-and-services" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">tools &amp; services</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/events" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">N.Y.C. events guide</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/multimedia" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">multimedia</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/section/lens" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">photography</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/video" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">video</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/newsletters" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">Newsletters</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/store" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">NYT store</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://www.nytimes.com/times-journeys" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">times journeys</a></li><li class="css-ist4u3"><a class="css-kwpx34" href="https://myaccount.nytimes.com/membercenter/myaccount.html" data-testid="site-index-section-list-link">manage my account</a></li></ul></section><div class="css-6xhk3s" aria-labelledby="site-index-subscribe-label"><h3 class="css-rxqrcl" id="site-index-subscribe-label">Subscribe</h3><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-subscribe-list"><li class="css-tj0ten"><a class="css-1k2cjfc" href="https://www.nytimes.com/hdleftnav" data-testid="site-index-subscribe-list-link"><svg class="css-r5ic95" viewBox="0 0 14 13" fill="#000"><path d="M13.1,11.7H3.5V1.2h9.6V11.7zM13.1,0.4H3.5C3,0.4,2.6,0.8,2.6,1.2v2.2H0.9C0.4,3.4,0,3.8,0,4.3v5.2v1.5c0,0.8,0.8,1.5,1.8,1.5h1.7h0h7.4h2.2c0.5,0,0.9-0.4,0.9-0.9V1.2C14,0.8,13.6,0.4,13.1,0.4"></path><polygon points="10.9,3 5.2,3 5.2,3.9 11.4,3.9 11.4,3"></polygon><rect x="5.2" y="4.7" width="6.1" height="0.9"></rect><rect x="5.2" y="6.5" width="6.1" height="0.9"></rect></svg>home delivery</a></li><li class="css-tj0ten"><a class="css-1k2cjfc" href="https://www.nytimes.com/digitalleftnav" data-testid="site-index-subscribe-list-link"><svg class="css-r5ic95" viewBox="0 0 10 13"><path fill="#000" d="M9.9,8c-0.4,1.1-1.2,1.9-2.3,2.4V8l1.3-1.2L7.6,5.7V4c1.2-0.1,2-1,2-2c0-1.4-1.3-1.9-2.1-1.9c-0.2,0-0.3,0-0.6,0.1v0.1c0.1,0,0.2,0,0.3,0c0.5,0,0.9,0.2,0.9,0.7c0,0.4-0.3,0.7-0.8,0.7C6,1.7,4.5,0.6,2.8,0.6c-1.5,0-2.5,1.1-2.5,2.2C0.3,4,1,4.3,1.6,4.6l0-0.1C1.4,4.4,1.3,4.1,1.3,3.8c0-0.5,0.5-0.9,1-0.9C3.7,2.9,6,4,7.4,4h0.1v1.7L6.2,6.8L7.5,8v2.4c-0.5,0.2-1.1,0.3-1.7,0.3c-2.2,0-3.6-1.3-3.6-3.5c0-0.5,0.1-1,0.2-1.5l1.1-0.5V10l2.2-1v-5L2.5,5.5c0.3-1,1-1.7,1.8-2l0,0C2.2,3.9,0.1,5.6,0.1,8c0,2.9,2.4,4.8,5.2,4.8C8.2,12.9,9.9,10.9,9.9,8L9.9,8z"></path></svg>digital subscriptions</a></li><li class="css-tj0ten"><a class="css-1k2cjfc" href="https://www.nytimes.com/subscription/games/lp897H9.html" data-testid="site-index-subscribe-list-link"><svg class="css-r5ic95" viewBox="0 0 13 13" fill="#000"><polygon points="0,-93.6 0,-86.9 6.6,-93.6"></polygon><polygon points="0.9,-86 7.5,-86 7.5,-92.6"></polygon><polygon points="0,-98 0,-94.8 8.8,-94.8 8.8,-86 12,-86 12,-98"></polygon><path d="M11.9-40c-0.4,1.1-1.2,1.9-2.3,2.4V-40l1.3-1.2l-1.3-1.2V-44c1.2-0.1,2-1,2-2c0-1.4-1.3-1.9-2.1-1.9c-0.2,0-0.3,0-0.6,0.1v0.1c0.1,0,0.2,0,0.3,0c0.5,0,0.9,0.2,0.9,0.7c0,0.4-0.3,0.7-0.8,0.7c-1.3,0-2.8-1.1-4.5-1.1c-1.5,0-2.5,1.1-2.5,2.2c0,1.1,0.6,1.5,1.3,1.7l0-0.1c-0.2-0.1-0.4-0.4-0.4-0.7c0-0.5,0.5-0.9,1-0.9C5.7-45.1,8-44,9.4-44h0.1v1.7l-1.3,1.1L9.5-40v2.4c-0.5,0.2-1.1,0.3-1.7,0.3c-2.2,0-3.6-1.3-3.6-3.5c0-0.5,0.1-1,0.2-1.5l1.1-0.5v4.9l2.2-1v-5l-3.3,1.5c0.3-1,1-1.7,1.8-2l0,0c-2.2,0.5-4.3,2.1-4.3,4.6c0,2.9,2.4,4.8,5.2,4.8C10.2-35.1,11.9-37.1,11.9-40L11.9-40z"></path><path d="M12.2-23.7c-0.2,0-0.4,0.2-0.4,0.4v0.4L0.4-19.1v2.3l3,1l-0.2,0.6c-0.3,0.8,0.1,1.8,0.9,2.1l1.7,0.7c0.2,0.1,0.4,0.1,0.6,0.1c0.6,0,1.3-0.4,1.5-1l0.4-0.9l3.5,1.2v0.4c0,0.2,0.2,0.4,0.4,0.4c0.2,0,0.4-0.2,0.4-0.4v-10.7C12.6-23.5,12.4-23.7,12.2-23.7M7.1-13.6c-0.2,0.4-0.6,0.6-1,0.4l-1.7-0.7c-0.4-0.2-0.6-0.6-0.4-1l0.3-0.7l3.3,1.1L7.1-13.6z"></path><path d="M13.1-60.3H3.5v-10.5h9.6V-60.3zM13.1-71.6H3.5c-0.5,0-0.9,0.4-0.9,0.9v2.2H0.9c-0.5,0-0.9,0.4-0.9,0.9v5.2v1.5c0,0.8,0.8,1.5,1.8,1.5h1.7h0h7.4h2.2c0.5,0,0.9-0.4,0.9-0.9v-10.5C14-71.2,13.6-71.6,13.1-71.6"></path><polygon points="10.9,-69 5.2,-69 5.2,-68.1 11.4,-68.1 11.4,-69"></polygon><rect x="5.2" y="-67.3" width="6.1" height="0.9"></rect><rect x="5.2" y="-65.5" width="6.1" height="0.9"></rect><path d="M12,6.5H6.5V12H1V6.5h5.5V1H12V6.5zM12,0H1C0.4,0,0,0.5,0,1v11c0,0.6,0.4,1,1,1h11c0.5,0,1-0.4,1-1V1C13,0.5,12.5,0,12,0"></path></svg>Crossword</a></li><li class="css-tj0ten"><a class="css-1k2cjfc" href="https://www.nytimes.com/subscriptions/Multiproduct/lp8R3WU.html" data-testid="site-index-subscribe-list-link"><svg class="css-r5ic95" viewBox="0 0 13 13" fill="#000"><path d="M12,2.9L9.6,5.2c-0.1,0.1-0.3,0.1-0.4,0C9.1,5.2,9.1,5,9.3,4.9l2.4-2.4c-0.2-0.2-0.3-0.3-0.5-0.5L8.7,4.3c-0.1,0.1-0.3,0.1-0.4,0C8.2,4.3,8.2,4.1,8.4,4l2.4-2.4c-0.3-0.3-0.5-0.5-0.5-0.5L7.6,3.4C7.1,4,6.8,5.1,7.1,5.8c-1.4,1-4.6,3.5-5.1,4c-0.8,0.8-0.4,1.8-0.3,1.9c0,0,0,0,0,0c0,0,0,0,0,0c0.1,0.1,1.1,0.5,1.9-0.3c0.4-0.4,2.9-3.6,3.9-5C8.4,6.9,9.6,6.6,10.2,6l2.3-2.6C12.5,3.4,12.3,3.2,12,2.9z"></path><path d="M0.8,1.9l0.3-0.3c0.9-0.9,3.2,1.1,3.8,1.7s0.9,1.8,0.4,2.6c1.4,1.1,4.6,3.5,5,3.9c0.8,0.8,0.4,1.8,0.3,1.9c0,0,0,0,0,0c0,0,0,0,0,0c-0.1,0.1-1.1,0.5-1.9-0.3c-0.4-0.4-2.9-3.7-4-5.1C3.9,6.7,2.9,6.4,2.3,5.8S-0.2,2.9,0.8,1.9z"></path></svg>Cooking</a></li></ul><ul class="css-1iruc8t" data-testid="site-index-corporate-links"><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://www.nytimes.com/marketing/newsletters">email newsletters</a></li><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://www.nytimes.com/corporateleftnav">corporate subscriptions</a></li><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://www.nytimes.com/educationleftnav">education rate</a></li></ul><ul class="css-6td9kr" data-testid="site-index-alternate-links"><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://www.nytimes.com/services/mobile/index.html">mobile applications</a></li><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="http://eedition.nytimes.com/cgi-bin/signup.cgi?cc=37FYY">replica edition</a></li><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://www.nytimes.com/es/">Español</a></li><li><a class="css-1vhk1ks" href="https://cn.nytimes.com/">中文网</a></li></ul></div></div></div></div></nav><footer role="contentinfo" class="css-1qmnftd e5u916q0"><nav data-testid="footer" class="css-15uy5yv"><h2 class="css-vz7hjd">Site Information Navigation</h2><ul class="css-1ho5u4o e5u916q1"><li data-testid="copyright"><a class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014792127-Copyright-notice">© <span itemProp="copyrightYear">2019</span><span itemProp="publisher copyrightHolder provider sourceOrganization" itemscope="" itemType="http://schema.org/NewsMediaOrganization" itemID="https://www.nytimes.com"> <meta itemProp="diversityPolicy" content="https://www.nytco.com/diversity-and-inclusion-at-the-new-york-times/"/><meta itemProp="ethicsPolicy" content="https://www.nytco.com/who-we-are/culture/standards-and-ethics/"/><meta itemProp="foundingDate" content="1851-09-18"/><span itemProp="logo" itemscope="" itemType="https://schema.org/ImageObject"><meta itemProp="url" content="https://static01.nyt.com/images/misc/NYT_logo_rss_250x40.png"/></span><meta itemProp="url" content="https://www.nytimes.com/"/><meta itemProp="masthead" content="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/09/28/admin/the-new-york-times-masthead.html"/><meta itemProp="name" content="The New York Times"/><span>The New York Times Company</span></span></a></li></ul><ul class="css-13o0c9t e5u916q2"><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115015385887-Contact-Us">Contact Us</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://www.nytco.com/careers/">Work with us</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://nytmediakit.com/">Advertise</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="http://www.tbrandstudio.com/">T Brand Studio</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014892108-Privacy-policy">Your Ad Choices</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014892108-Privacy-policy">Privacy</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014893428-Terms-of-service">Terms of Service</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us/articles/115014893968-Terms-of-sale">Terms of Sale</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="http://spiderbites.nytimes.com">Site Map</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://help.nytimes.com/hc/en-us">Help</a></li><li class="css-1yo489b e5u916q3"><a data-testid="footer-link" class="css-1p8nkc0" href="https://www.nytimes.com/subscription?campaignId=37WXW">Subscriptions</a></li></ul></nav></footer></div></div></div></div></div>
<script>window.__preloadedData = {"config":{"gqlUrl":"https:\u002F\u002Fsamizdat-graphql.nytimes.com\u002Fgraphql\u002Fv2","gqlRequestHeaders":{"nyt-app-type":"project-vi","nyt-app-version":"0.0.5","nyt-token":"MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAs+\u002FoUCTBmD\u002FcLdmcecrnBMHiU\u002FpxQCn2DDyaPKUOXxi4p0uUSZQzsuq1pJ1m5z1i0YGPd1U1OeGHAChWtqoxC7bFMCXcwnE1oyui9G1uobgpm1GdhtwkR7ta7akVTcsF8zxiXx7DNXIPd2nIJFH83rmkZueKrC4JVaNzjvD+Z03piLn5bHWU6+w+rA+kyJtGgZNTXKyPh6EC6o5N+rknNMG5+CdTq35p8f99WjFawSvYgP9V64kgckbTbtdJ6YhVP58TnuYgr12urtwnIqWP9KSJ1e5vmgf3tunMqWNm6+AnsqNj8mCLdCuc5cEB74CwUeQcP2HQQmbCddBy2y0mEwIDAQAB"},"gqlFetchTimeout":4000,"disablePersistedQueries":false,"initialDeviceType":"desktop","fastlyAbraConfig":{},"serviceWorkerFile":"service-worker-test-1568405453531.js"},"interactiveConfig":{"interactive":{"displayProperties":{"fullBleedDisplayStyle":"","__typename":"CreativeWorkDisplayProperties","maxWidth":1600,"minWidth":300,"displayForPromotionOnly":false,"template":"Standard","displayOverrides":[],"displayStyle":"standard","theme":"standard"},"section":{"id":"U2VjdGlvbjpueXQ6Ly9zZWN0aW9uL2EzNGQzZDZjLWM3N2YtNTkzMS1iOTUxLTI0MWI0ZTI4NjgxYw==","name":"us","__typename":"Section","url":"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.nytimes.com\u002Fsection\u002Fus","displayName":"U.S.","taxonomyID":"23FD6C8B-62D5-4CEA-A331-6C2A9A1223BE","type":"section","uri":"nyt:\u002F\u002Fsection\u002Fa34d3d6c-c77f-5931-b951-241b4e28681c"},"subsection":{"id":"U2VjdGlvbjpueXQ6Ly9zZWN0aW9uLzcyOTI2MGRjLTg3NjUtNWU3Yi1hN2FjLTFmYzdmZDUwMTMyNQ==","name":"elections","__typename":"Section","url":"\u002Fnews-event\u002F2020-election","displayName":"Elections","taxonomyID":"","uri":"nyt:\u002F\u002Fsection\u002F729260dc-8765-5e7b-a7ac-1fc7fd501325"},"tone":"NEWS","collections":[{"id":"TGVnYWN5Q29sbGVjdGlvbjpueXQ6Ly9sZWdhY3ljb2xsZWN0aW9uLzM1MGVkYTcxLTM2M2ItNWIyYi1hNzlkLTc4YWRlMzNlZGM3OA==","name":"Election 2020","collectionType":"NEWS_EVENT","__typename":"LegacyCollection","url":"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.nytimes.com\u002Fnews-event\u002F2020-election","uri":"nyt:\u002F\u002Flegacycollection\u002F350eda71-363b-5b2b-a79d-78ade33edc78","slug":"2020-election","tagline":"Read the latest on the 2020 election, including coverage of President Trump, Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and more."},{"id":"TGVnYWN5Q29sbGVjdGlvbjpueXQ6Ly9sZWdhY3ljb2xsZWN0aW9uLzExZjcyYWI0LTdjZDAtNTQwYS05M2NjLWYzNWIzMmNkMDEzZA==","name":"U.S. News","collectionType":"SECTION","__typename":"LegacyCollection","url":"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.nytimes.com\u002Fsection\u002Fus","uri":"nyt:\u002F\u002Flegacycollection\u002F11f72ab4-7cd0-540a-93cc-f35b32cd013d","slug":"us","tagline":""}],"url":"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.nytimes.com\u002Finteractive\u002F2019\u002F07\u002F31\u002Fus\u002Felections\u002Fdebate-speaking-time.html","sourceId":"100000006640050","dfpTaxonomyException":"us\u002Fpolitics\u002Felections","advertisingProperties":{"sensitivity":"SHOW_ADS","__typename":"CreativeWorkAdvertisingProperties"},"adTargetingParams":[{"key":"als_test","value":"1568448529347","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"prop","value":"nyt","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"plat","value":"web","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"edn","value":"us","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"brandsensitive","value":"false","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"per","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"org","value":"democraticparty","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"geo","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"des","value":"presidentialelectionof2020","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"spon","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"auth","value":"aliciaparlapiano,jasmineclee,weiyicai","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"col","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"coll","value":"election2020,usnews","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"artlen","value":"short","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"ledemedsz","value":"none","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"gui","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"template","value":"interactive","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"typ","value":"int","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"section","value":"us","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"si_section","value":"us","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"id","value":"100000006640050","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"trend","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"pt","value":"nt1,nt11,nt13,nt17,nt5,nt7","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"gscat","value":"gs_politics,gs_politics_misc,gs_politics_american,gs_science,famine,gs_science_environ,gs_health_misc,gs_health,neg_fcli,neg_chanel,gv_safe","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"tt","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"},{"key":"mt","value":"","__typename":"AdTargetingParam"}],"headline":{"default":"Joe Biden and Kamala Harris Got the Most Speaking Time During the Democratic Debate","__typename":"CreativeWorkHeadline","seo":""},"summary":"Follow along live during the debate.","shortUrl":"https:\u002F\u002Fnyti.ms\u002F2ypDmZH","commentStatus":"NO_COMMENTS","uri":"nyt:\u002F\u002Finteractive\u002F0fdf9ad9-54f9-591e-a71e-7477603238cb","storylines":[]}},"statusCode":200};</script>
<script>!function(e){function r(r){for(var n,i,a=r[0],f=r[1],l=r[2],p=0,s=[];p<a.length;p++)i=a[p],o[i]&&s.push(o[i][0]),o[i]=0;for(n in f)Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(f,n)&&(e[n]=f[n]);for(c&&c(r);s.length;)s.shift()();return u.push.apply(u,l||[]),t()}function t(){for(var e,r=0;r<u.length;r++){for(var t=u[r],n=!0,a=1;a<t.length;a++){var f=t[a];0!==o[f]&&(n=!1)}n&&(u.splice(r--,1),e=i(i.s=t[0]))}return e}var n={},o={37:0},u=[];function i(r){if(n[r])return n[r].exports;var t=n[r]={i:r,l:!1,exports:{}};return e[r].call(t.exports,t,t.exports,i),t.l=!0,t.exports}i.m=e,i.c=n,i.d=function(e,r,t){i.o(e,r)||Object.defineProperty(e,r,{enumerable:!0,get:t})},i.r=function(e){"undefined"!=typeof Symbol&&Symbol.toStringTag&&Object.defineProperty(e,Symbol.toStringTag,{value:"Module"}),Object.defineProperty(e,"__esModule",{value:!0})},i.t=function(e,r){if(1&r&&(e=i(e)),8&r)return e;if(4&r&&"object"==typeof e&&e&&e.__esModule)return e;var t=Object.create(null);if(i.r(t),Object.defineProperty(t,"default",{enumerable:!0,value:e}),2&r&&"string"!=typeof e)for(var n in e)i.d(t,n,function(r){return e[r]}.bind(null,n));return t},i.n=function(e){var r=e&&e.__esModule?function(){return e.default}:function(){return e};return i.d(r,"a",r),r},i.o=function(e,r){return Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(e,r)},i.p="/vi-assets/static-assets/";var a=window.webpackJsonp=window.webpackJsonp||[],f=a.push.bind(a);a.push=r,a=a.slice();for(var l=0;l<a.length;l++)r(a[l]);var c=f;t()}([]);
//# sourceMappingURL=runtime~adslot-a45e9d5711d983de8fda.js.map</script>
<script async src="/vi-assets/static-assets/adslot-e17e56641f99c9bdce81.js"></script>
<script>!function(e){function t(t){for(var n,i,a=t[0],c=t[1],l=t[2],s=0,p=[];s<a.length;s++)i=a[s],o[i]&&p.push(o[i][0]),o[i]=0;for(n in c)Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(c,n)&&(e[n]=c[n]);for(f&&f(t);p.length;)p.shift()();return u.push.apply(u,l||[]),r()}function r(){for(var e,t=0;t<u.length;t++){for(var r=u[t],n=!0,a=1;a<r.length;a++){var c=r[a];0!==o[c]&&(n=!1)}n&&(u.splice(t--,1),e=i(i.s=r[0]))}return e}var n={},o={38:0},u=[];function i(t){if(n[t])return n[t].exports;var r=n[t]={i:t,l:!1,exports:{}};return e[t].call(r.exports,r,r.exports,i),r.l=!0,r.exports}i.e=function(e){var t=[],r=o[e];if(0!==r)if(r)t.push(r[2]);else{var n=new Promise(function(t,n){r=o[e]=[t,n]});t.push(r[2]=n);var u,a=document.createElement("script");a.charset="utf-8",a.timeout=120,i.nc&&a.setAttribute("nonce",i.nc),a.src=function(e){return i.p+""+({21:"comments"}[e]||e)+"-"+{21:"d1c0236cae2a10a1e849"}[e]+".js"}(e),u=function(t){a.onerror=a.onload=null,clearTimeout(c);var r=o[e];if(0!==r){if(r){var n=t&&("load"===t.type?"missing":t.type),u=t&&t.target&&t.target.src,i=new Error("Loading chunk "+e+" failed.\n("+n+": "+u+")");i.type=n,i.request=u,r[1](i)}o[e]=void 0}};var c=setTimeout(function(){u({type:"timeout",target:a})},12e4);a.onerror=a.onload=u,document.head.appendChild(a)}return Promise.all(t)},i.m=e,i.c=n,i.d=function(e,t,r){i.o(e,t)||Object.defineProperty(e,t,{enumerable:!0,get:r})},i.r=function(e){"undefined"!=typeof Symbol&&Symbol.toStringTag&&Object.defineProperty(e,Symbol.toStringTag,{value:"Module"}),Object.defineProperty(e,"__esModule",{value:!0})},i.t=function(e,t){if(1&t&&(e=i(e)),8&t)return e;if(4&t&&"object"==typeof e&&e&&e.__esModule)return e;var r=Object.create(null);if(i.r(r),Object.defineProperty(r,"default",{enumerable:!0,value:e}),2&t&&"string"!=typeof e)for(var n in e)i.d(r,n,function(t){return e[t]}.bind(null,n));return r},i.n=function(e){var t=e&&e.__esModule?function(){return e.default}:function(){return e};return i.d(t,"a",t),t},i.o=function(e,t){return Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(e,t)},i.p="/vi-assets/static-assets/",i.oe=function(e){throw console.error(e),e};var a=window.webpackJsonp=window.webpackJsonp||[],c=a.push.bind(a);a.push=t,a=a.slice();for(var l=0;l<a.length;l++)t(a[l]);var f=c;r()}([]);
//# sourceMappingURL=runtime~interactive-0c5af8a325f7e9c73f57.js.map</script>
<script defer src="/vi-assets/static-assets/vendor-48343b9fa8041121057c.js"></script>
<script defer src="/vi-assets/static-assets/comments-d1c0236cae2a10a1e849.js"></script>
<script defer src="/vi-assets/static-assets/interactive-e63e27c9102a766bf63d.js"></script>
<script>
(function(w, l) {
w[l] = w[l] || [];
w[l].push({
'gtm.start': new Date().getTime(),
event: 'gtm.js'
});
})(window, 'dataLayer');
</script>
<script defer src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-P528B3&gtm_auth=tfAzqo1rYDLgYhmTnSjPqw&gtm_preview=env-130&gtm_cookies_win=x"></script>
<noscript>
<iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-P528B3&gtm_auth=tfAzqo1rYDLgYhmTnSjPqw&gtm_preview=env-130&gtm_cookies_win=x" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe>
</noscript>
<div id="RavenInstaller">
<script>
if (window.INSTALL_RAVEN) {
window.addEventListener('load', function(event) {
var includeRaven = document.getElementById("RavenInstaller");
var script = document.createElement("script");
script.src = "/vi-assets/static-assets/raven.min-830a6d04a55c283934dd1893d6ddc66d.js";
script.onload = function() {
/* eslint-disable */
// Install Raven
window.Raven.config('https://7bc8bccf5c254286a99b11c68f6bf4ce@sentry.io/178860', {
release: vi.env.RELEASE,
environment: vi.env.ENVIRONMENT,
ignoreErrors: [/SecurityError: Blocked a frame with origin.*/]
}).install(); // Stop using our error handler
window.nyt_errors.ravenInstalled = true;
var regex = /nyt-a=(.*?)(;|$)/;
var id = regex.exec(document.cookie);
if (id !== null) {
id = id[1];
} else {
id = '';
} // Setting nyt-a as user context
window.Raven.setUserContext({
id: id
}); // Pass collected errors to Raven
window.nyt_errors.list.forEach(function (err) {
// weird?
if (!err) {
return;
} // also weird ... ?
if (!err.err) {
// maybe err itself is an Error?
if (err instanceof Error) {
window.Raven.captureException(err, err.data || {});
} // else { silently ignore? }
} // just making sure ...
if (err.err instanceof Error) {
window.Raven.captureException(err.err, err.data || {});
} // else { silently ignore? }
}); // Pass collected Tags to Raven
window.nyt_errors.tags.forEach(function (tag) {
window.Raven.setTagsContext(tag);
});
};
includeRaven.appendChild(script);
});
}
</script>
</div>
</body>
</html>